From a913a9ab8a0801689388a413eb77495b50f36b8d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kewton Date: Thu, 17 Sep 2026 01:51:47 +0900 Subject: [PATCH] Align D4 inline admission before freeze (#488) --- dev-reports/issue-488/design.md | 72 ++ .../issue-488/implementation-summary.md | 47 ++ dev-reports/issue-488/node-observations.json | 506 +++++++++++ dev-reports/issue-488/planner-fallback.json | 92 ++ dev-reports/issue-488/planner-last-valid.json | 117 +++ dev-reports/issue-488/planner-refusals.json | 797 ++++++++++++++++++ dev-reports/issue-488/planner-success.json | 413 +++++++++ dev-reports/issue-488/verification.md | 127 +++ .../evidence/command_diagnosis.rs | 30 + .../final_acceptance/issue488_tests.rs | 206 +++++ src/planner/recovery_contract_authority.rs | 16 +- .../inline_admission.rs | 45 + .../verifier_obligations.rs | 6 +- src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding.rs | 1 + .../recovery_step_plan_binding/admission.rs | 48 +- .../issue466_tests.rs | 3 + .../issue484_tests.rs | 4 +- .../issue488_planner_tests.rs | 414 +++++++++ .../issue488_registration_tests.rs | 238 ++++++ .../issue488_runtime_tests.rs | 92 ++ .../issue488_tests.rs | 119 +++ .../literal_marker_formation.rs | 220 +++++ .../verifier_formation.rs | 26 + .../runner/phase/recovery_authority.rs | 4 + .../corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/README.md | 84 ++ .../issue488-d4-inline/business-controls.json | 5 + .../apps/issue488-d4-inline/commands.json | 18 + .../apps/issue488-d4-inline/contract.json | 19 + .../apps/issue488-d4-inline/expectations.toml | 18 + .../issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/input.txt | 3 + .../issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/normal.txt | 4 + .../issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/primary.txt | 3 + .../issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/snapshot.txt | 3 + .../issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/state.txt | 3 + .../apps/issue488-d4-inline/matrix.json | 242 ++++++ .../apps/issue488-d4-inline/refusals.json | 17 + .../issue488-d4-inline/source-manifest.json | 21 + .../apps/issue488-d4-inline/src/app/page.tsx | 4 + 38 files changed, 4069 insertions(+), 18 deletions(-) create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/design.md create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/implementation-summary.md create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/node-observations.json create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/planner-fallback.json create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/planner-last-valid.json create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/planner-refusals.json create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/planner-success.json create mode 100644 dev-reports/issue-488/verification.md create mode 100644 src/planner/final_acceptance/issue488_tests.rs create mode 100644 src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/inline_admission.rs create mode 100644 src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_planner_tests.rs create mode 100644 src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_registration_tests.rs create mode 100644 src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_runtime_tests.rs create mode 100644 src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_tests.rs create mode 100644 src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/literal_marker_formation.rs create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/README.md create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/business-controls.json create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/commands.json create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/contract.json create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/expectations.toml create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/input.txt create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/normal.txt create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/primary.txt create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/snapshot.txt create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/state.txt create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/matrix.json create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/refusals.json create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/source-manifest.json create mode 100644 tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/src/app/page.tsx diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/design.md b/dev-reports/issue-488/design.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..de6f7578 --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/design.md @@ -0,0 +1,72 @@ +# Issue #488 design + +Baseline: `85dd5fdd12b831deb49e7b3fe9e996c01f1fab67`, clean dedicated +`feature/issue-488-cli-acceptance-d4-inline` worktree. No predecessors assigned. +Read the complete parent-saved Issue body, worker skill and development guardrails. +Parent `e99f1ebe` plus WIP and historical C5 `f0aceed8` are separate contexts; +neither is an implementation source to copy or cherry-pick. +Relevant committed ancestors inspected: `3c814d91` (#479 verifier formation), +`d9ad6f5d` (#480 executed failure predicates), and `7125ce93` (#484 package-script +formation). `HEAD` and the dedicated worktree's `origin/develop` both resolve to +the full baseline SHA above; no parent mixed-worktree changes were assumed merged. + +## Existing coverage and reproduction plan + +The actual Runner calls Admission after normalization, augmentation and policy +sanitization, before lint, and uses Admission::finish on every fallback return. +#479 already rejects weak inline commands here using the final classifier; #484 +adds captured package-script obligations. Those changes are in this baseline. +The three registration paths are register_step_plan_commands, +verifier_obligations::register and complete_generated_verify_commands (handoff). +They validate command policy but do not check immutable weak evidence. +The baseline has no source_verifier_admission or C5 fixed_verifier_routing module. +Existing profile and final-acceptance gates remain authoritative and unchanged. + +Before production edits, reproduce exact D4 command classification, Admission +retry, rejected requirement-preserving rewrite and registration bypass with real +functions. Preserve command bytes/hashes from the read-only historical input; +use new reduced marker fixtures, not the disqualified historical argv recorder. + +## Smallest change + +Keep the existing broad formation rejection. Add a leaf registration guard for +new final-success literal inline Node candidates only when trusted Config says +Next.js/create, current-run provenance owns the generated unconfigured contract, +and normalized trusted requirements make their source-independent weak evidence +gate relevant. Use the final classifier and requirement evaluation, not a second +weakness heuristic. Validate the entire candidate batch before persistence or +producer-obligation updates. Existing configured/closed handling is unchanged. + +Extend preclosure projection with a closed whole-program grammar for literal +file marker predicates: ordered literal-regex throw/assert or swallowed includes +assert to direct includes assert. Preserve path, all ordered conditions, messages, +success stdout and expected result; only literal regexes with escaped metacharacters +qualify. No arbitrary JS equivalence. The existing model/host scope projection +must still enforce outputs, responsible owners and execution boundaries. Record +original command, normalized command, source step and checked replacement. +Allow this projection only for owned eligible draft checks, never frozen checks. + +## Verification + +New corpus and focused Rust tests cover exact four commands on normal, four +single-missing-marker and missing-file fixtures with real Node; final static +classification and actual execution remain separate. Mock-provider tests capture +actual request bodies and returned plans for repair, exhaustion, scope loss and +fallback. Test both mixed candidate orders and all-good batches at all registration +entries; authority/requirements controls; existing profile gates, independent +business failure, compile/missing requirements and identity preservation. +Run focused tests, related corpus, fmt check, clippy with warnings denied and full +cargo test. Record failures honestly. No live model, browser, build-success claim, +parent WIP edit, runtime namespace change, push or external lifecycle operation. + +## Baseline dynamic result (before production edits) + +`cargo test issue488_baseline --lib -- --nocapture` passed on the baseline with +only corpus/test additions (1 test). Actual Admission returned Retry for O/V1/ +SWALLOW, Ready for V2; StepPlan registration accepted all four; final static +acceptance rejected O/V1/SWALLOW and passed V2. The V2 rewrite after a weak first +proposal was rejected by exact-command preservation. Thus normal weak refusal +already exists, but registration defense and supported rewrite formation are +unmet. No C5 routing transplant is needed. First test compilation failed because +the test supplied typed deferred requirements to the string API; corrected the +empty fixture argument before obtaining this result. diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/implementation-summary.md b/dev-reports/issue-488/implementation-summary.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..3f5cb499 --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/implementation-summary.md @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +# Issue #488 implementation + +At baseline `85dd5fdd12b831deb49e7b3fe9e996c01f1fab67`, #479 already returned +D4 O/V1/SWALLOW to proposal repair. The unmet boundaries were direct registration +and accepting a supported requirement-preserving rewrite. The pre-change dynamic +reproduction is recorded in design.md; this is not the old C5 behavior replayed +as if it were current develop. + +- Added a small registration guard at command, StepPlan/producer and empty + handoff registration. It validates the entire normalized/policy-checked batch + before contract persistence, producer changes or success events. The existing + final classifier is run without workspace files and its weak reason passes + through final acceptance's requirement normalization/pruning. +- Scoped this guard to trusted Config Next.js/create, a same-run owned generated + unconfigured contract, new final-success inline literal candidates and a + gate-relevant weak reason. Existing broader formation rejection is retained. + Both profile checks use the existing `profile::is_nextjs_profile` boundary; + the final-acceptance test module uses the repository's cfg(test) convention. + Generality guardrail expectations, scanner and baselines are unchanged. +- Added finite whole-program literal-marker formation: regex literal throw/assert + or swallowed includes predicates may become direct includes assertions only + with identical file, ordered conditions, diagnostic messages and success stdout. + Existing model/host scope projection retains other commands, outputs, responsible + owners, expected results and boundaries. Raw proposals cannot hide a shell + wrapper behind sanitizer normalization. +- Reused the existing three planner proposals and fallback finish checks. The + new guard also checks final candidate returns. Added optional replacement + metadata to the existing event; no old event name/field/schema was removed. +- Added exact-command/hash corpus, 24 reduced runtime cases, full final-executor + controls, captured mock requests/returns, registration all-or-nothing tests, + authority controls, synthetic independent business/compile failure boundaries + and frozen-byte identity rejection. Actual last-valid returns and clearing + are separate from direct finish tests. + +No final classifier promotion, requirement downgrade, added retry/Recovery +budget, new fixed-verifier routing, parent WIP transplant, guardrail baseline +change, live runtime namespace change or external action is part of this change. +The baseline has no parent-WIP source_verifier_admission module; existing Next.js +profile/build/behavior and identity checks remain separate. V2 passing a text +check does not establish an application's business behavior. + +The evidence JSON files are curated test observations and captured request bodies, +not historical or live run logs. Node v24.1.0 ran locally. `classifier_parser_argv` +is the argument vector supplied to the direct Node control. Only status/stdout/ +stderr are compared with shell execution; shell-process argv is not observed. +No live model API or browser experiment was performed. The new D4 measurements +do not establish a successful application build or business workflow. diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/node-observations.json b/dev-reports/issue-488/node-observations.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..3c408778 --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/node-observations.json @@ -0,0 +1,506 @@ +[ + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "normal", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "O", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "primary", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "O", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "Error: missing primary", + "stderr_sha256": "c510ef0fcba4fd6ac4e8df1c55e5e123b5204c39a2cb34489c5f90bddad3779a", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "input", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "O", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "Error: missing input", + "stderr_sha256": "0c09e7d715c4ba1dc6764a81adca3505ecca2829470d39ddb09bba4a813a13d3", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "state", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "O", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "Error: missing state", + "stderr_sha256": "54e004168b1d7153d46a5100be34c9ad604e92ad1ef7f1c8d7dc425a80e5e376", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "snapshot", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "O", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "Error: missing JSON snapshot", + "stderr_sha256": "eb85692c0b381b80df4b9246a0bb44defa1cfedd17835ce960d16f38cbf08707", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "file_missing", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "O", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open 'src/app/page.tsx'", + "stderr_sha256": "ec20f1ad0c4b3d184b4034e79c348c06d9253ce2691a3c17ef5f9c3b01e7205c", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s),\"missing primary\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s),\"missing input\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\"missing state\"); assert(/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "normal", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "V1", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s),\"missing primary\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s),\"missing input\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\"missing state\"); assert(/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "primary", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "V1", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing primary", + "stderr_sha256": "710e8f4b35499208867573ee887e3b92ff12758658ff220be3cfd7fc81fdd3f9", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s),\"missing primary\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s),\"missing input\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\"missing state\"); assert(/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "input", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "V1", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing input", + "stderr_sha256": "c7fdd500f6059e05b2eafc4f3528f3717892e4340556d966b7a67bd3ebcdf88d", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s),\"missing primary\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s),\"missing input\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\"missing state\"); assert(/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "state", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "V1", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing state", + "stderr_sha256": "448434b00b2434d80f04c980408978f36f76fa29e70cafa7d9e8a078249f5f93", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s),\"missing primary\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s),\"missing input\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\"missing state\"); assert(/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "snapshot", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "V1", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing JSON snapshot", + "stderr_sha256": "6d8c5b5d06fd912352f11f3cb8ad162ab25964463e3fe0315a159fab3a568e84", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"primary\"/.test(s),\"missing primary\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\"input\"/.test(s),\"missing input\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\"missing state\"); assert(/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "file_missing", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "V1", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open 'src/app/page.tsx'", + "stderr_sha256": "d3153e96ecdd61aeb3ddac6a0a16167939d1a985beaf0007eacd04cc27dbdf0a", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "test", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "normal", + "formation": "ready", + "name": "V2", + "registration": "accepted", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": true, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "test", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "primary", + "formation": "ready", + "name": "V2", + "registration": "accepted", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": true, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing primary", + "stderr_sha256": "710e8f4b35499208867573ee887e3b92ff12758658ff220be3cfd7fc81fdd3f9", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "test", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "input", + "formation": "ready", + "name": "V2", + "registration": "accepted", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": true, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing input", + "stderr_sha256": "2e6f31927210eae84a92e0ea108b778221499d17bbb01dd1a3a438dae9a91039", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "test", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "state", + "formation": "ready", + "name": "V2", + "registration": "accepted", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": true, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing state", + "stderr_sha256": "f91f179631afbe93422105187635346d18c57aef38d2be63a1e9d7d43d836b52", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "test", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "snapshot", + "formation": "ready", + "name": "V2", + "registration": "accepted", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": true, + "stderr_failure": "AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: missing JSON snapshot", + "stderr_sha256": "1e7a967310482fa1e3cba1f93681812aebd17e5e3c216695a181c87bbe86c245", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "test", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\"); console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "file_missing", + "formation": "ready", + "name": "V2", + "registration": "accepted", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": true, + "stderr_failure": "Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open 'src/app/page.tsx'", + "stderr_sha256": "d3153e96ecdd61aeb3ddac6a0a16167939d1a985beaf0007eacd04cc27dbdf0a", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "normal", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "SWALLOW", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "primary", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "SWALLOW", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "input", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "SWALLOW", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "state", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "SWALLOW", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": true, + "exit_code": 0, + "fixture": "snapshot", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "SWALLOW", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": null, + "stderr_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "stdout": "ok\n", + "success": true + }, + { + "classification": "weak", + "classifier_parser_argv": [ + "node", + "-e", + "const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"primary\"'),\"missing primary\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\"input\"'),\"missing input\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\"missing state\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\"missing JSON snapshot\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')" + ], + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "execution_pass": false, + "exit_code": 1, + "fixture": "file_missing", + "formation": "retry", + "name": "SWALLOW", + "registration": "rejected", + "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match": true, + "static_acceptance": false, + "stderr_failure": "Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open 'src/app/page.tsx'", + "stderr_sha256": "d3153e96ecdd61aeb3ddac6a0a16167939d1a985beaf0007eacd04cc27dbdf0a", + "stdout": "", + "success": false + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-fallback.json b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-fallback.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c5eb895a --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-fallback.json @@ -0,0 +1,92 @@ +[ + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + } + ], + "error": "invalid StepPlan after corrective retries: StepPlan invalid JSON: no JSON object found", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "99b28754b12383dc4c27f83216866228399a1f714ce0e574d0bea9a680522406", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "da3f9059503d04b011645f93d9872cfc5560faa806ab055630e3e19e2e447352", + "user_body": "Your previous StepPlan output failed schema validation on attempt 2/3: StepPlan invalid JSON: no JSON object found.\nReturn only one JSON object and no markdown fences.\nDetected schema issues:\n- Return the canonical StepPlan JSON object with goal and steps.\n\nRequired JSON shape:\n{\n \"goal\": \"Verify saved source markers\",\n \"steps\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"kebab-id\",\n \"kind\": \"implement\",\n \"expected_result\": \"pass\",\n \"instruction\": \"Create the required files for the goal.\",\n \"expected_paths\": [\"relative/path\"],\n \"verify\": [\"command\"]\n }\n ]\n}\n\nRules:\n- Include top-level goal and non-empty steps.\n- Step id must be a quoted string, not a number.\n- expected_result must be exactly \"pass\" or \"fail\", not prose.\n- Keep expected_paths workspace-relative.\n- Use deterministic verify commands only.\n\nGoal: Verify saved source markers" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "no_last_valid_plan", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "planner_fallback_plan", + "planner_attempt": null, + "recovery_budget_changed": null, + "remaining_planner_attempts": null, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": null + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_return_rejected", + "planner_attempt": null, + "recovery_budget_changed": null, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": null + } + ], + "error": "cannot return fallback after verifier formation exhausted planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner src/app/page.tsx: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner src/app/page.tsx", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "5121eff7644b74353de50608c0d6a452d484373688fe29439cdb7a905f9ecab1", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nPhase id: setup\nPhase task: scaffold the project\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "6397c7a48df9988731c4ad4851de87963189641fe8ce177e40fc904620160ec5", + "user_body": "Goal: Phase id: setup\nPhase task: scaffold the project\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Phase id: setup\\nPhase task: scaffold the project\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Phase id: setup\\nPhase task: scaffold the project\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Phase id: setup\\nPhase task: scaffold the project\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Phase id: setup\\nPhase task: scaffold the project\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "5c6e27c772fdb7211946a73edd4b4ea653511fd83560321b2e687616feca5f93", + "user_body": "Your previous StepPlan output failed schema validation on attempt 2/3: StepPlan invalid JSON: no JSON object found.\nReturn only one JSON object and no markdown fences.\nDetected schema issues:\n- Return the canonical StepPlan JSON object with goal and steps.\n\nRequired JSON shape:\n{\n \"goal\": \"Phase id: setup\nPhase task: scaffold the project\",\n \"steps\": [\n {\n \"id\": \"kebab-id\",\n \"kind\": \"implement\",\n \"expected_result\": \"pass\",\n \"instruction\": \"Create the required files for the goal.\",\n \"expected_paths\": [\"relative/path\"],\n \"verify\": [\"command\"]\n }\n ]\n}\n\nRules:\n- Include top-level goal and non-empty steps.\n- Step id must be a quoted string, not a number.\n- expected_result must be exactly \"pass\" or \"fail\", not prose.\n- Keep expected_paths workspace-relative.\n- Use deterministic verify commands only.\n\nGoal: Phase id: setup\nPhase task: scaffold the project" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "setup_fallback", + "validated": [] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-last-valid.json b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-last-valid.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ae8e5c95 --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-last-valid.json @@ -0,0 +1,117 @@ +[ + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "planner_quality_retry", + "planner_attempt": null, + "recovery_budget_changed": null, + "remaining_planner_attempts": null, + "repair_attempt": 1, + "status": null + }, + { + "event": "planner_quality_retry_degraded", + "planner_attempt": null, + "recovery_budget_changed": null, + "remaining_planner_attempts": null, + "repair_attempt": 2, + "status": null + }, + { + "event": "planner_quality_retry_degraded", + "planner_attempt": null, + "recovery_budget_changed": null, + "remaining_planner_attempts": null, + "repair_attempt": 3, + "status": null + } + ], + "error": null, + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "f33597ecf99fecae3d73e615f8556f1691faa12073218c7a6138fc7c08d2d513", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nBuild a Next.js game app\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "7810416998b9d90e2da88dd221727974806cb8c480bf4c68f854dd1667e51d6d", + "user_body": "Your previous StepPlan was schema-valid and passed safety lint, but it had retryable quality issues on attempt 1/3.\nImprove the plan without weakening safety rules:\n- [profile_verify_missing] profile expects deterministic build/test verification but plan has no preferred verify command evidence=npm run build\n\nHard constraints:\n- Keep the original top-level goal unchanged.\n- Keep expected_paths workspace-relative and owned by one setup/implement step.\n- Keep verify commands deterministic, single commands, and free of shell control syntax.\n- Do not start dev servers or perform dependency installation in verify.\n- Prefer tests, builds, smoke checks, or content assertions over file existence checks.\n- For Next.js, put package.json and app entrypoints before npm run build.\n\n- Do not add a final report step for normal success; report is only for explicit blockers.\n- In a fresh create/scaffold workspace, start with setup/implement work that owns an artifact instead of an empty inspect wrapper.\n- Keep verify-only steps connected to prior artifacts through the verify command or step instruction.\n\nReturn only one JSON object with top-level goal and steps. Do not use markdown fences.\nGoal: Build a Next.js game app" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "5e7a4df35ffea1f9d8ec3a5b04fd4d184de00222ecbcc93505201ba09e1e963d", + "user_body": "Your previous StepPlan failed deterministic lint on attempt 2/3.\nFix these issues without weakening safety rules:\n- [verify_policy] verify command may not use shell control syntax; allowed alternatives: use one deterministic command such as `npm run build`, `cargo test`, `python -m compileall -q src`, or `test -f relative/path`; split multiple checks into separate verify commands; rejected original_command: \"node check.js | node check2.js\"\n\nHard constraints to preserve in the corrected plan:\n- Keep the original top-level goal unchanged.\n- Use setup, implement, verify, and report responsibilities separately.\n- Implement/setup steps own expected_paths; verify-only steps should normally have empty expected_paths.\n- Each implementation-owned expected path must have exactly one owner step.\n- Verify commands must be single commands without &&, ||, |, ;, backticks, or command substitution.\n- Split multiple checks into multiple verify steps or multiple verify list items.\n- Preserve the verification meaning; do not replace a real check with a weak file-existence check.\n- Move setup, dependency installation, and dev-server readiness into setup/implement instructions or external postcheck, not verify.\n- If a Node smoke check needs multiple statements, create a smoke-check.js artifact in an implement step and verify with a single command such as node smoke-check.js.\n- If documentation needs multiple assertions, prefer separate grep -q commands in the verify list, each checking one phrase in one file.\n\nReturn only one JSON object with top-level goal and steps. Do not use markdown fences.\nStep id must be a quoted string. expected_result must be exactly \"pass\" or \"fail\".\nGoal: Build a Next.js game app" + } + ], + "returned_plan": { + "goal": "Build a Next.js game app", + "steps": [ + { + "expected_paths": [ + "package.json", + "src/app/page.tsx" + ], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "make-app", + "instruction": "Create package.json and src/app/page.tsx for the game app\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).", + "kind": "implement", + "verify": [ + "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"" + ] + } + ] + }, + "series": "last_valid_return_after_quality_then_lint_then_schema", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "planner_quality_retry", + "planner_attempt": null, + "recovery_budget_changed": null, + "remaining_planner_attempts": null, + "repair_attempt": 1, + "status": null + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + } + ], + "error": "invalid StepPlan after corrective retries: StepPlan invalid JSON: no JSON object found", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "f33597ecf99fecae3d73e615f8556f1691faa12073218c7a6138fc7c08d2d513", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nBuild a Next.js game app\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "7810416998b9d90e2da88dd221727974806cb8c480bf4c68f854dd1667e51d6d", + "user_body": "Your previous StepPlan was schema-valid and passed safety lint, but it had retryable quality issues on attempt 1/3.\nImprove the plan without weakening safety rules:\n- [profile_verify_missing] profile expects deterministic build/test verification but plan has no preferred verify command evidence=npm run build\n\nHard constraints:\n- Keep the original top-level goal unchanged.\n- Keep expected_paths workspace-relative and owned by one setup/implement step.\n- Keep verify commands deterministic, single commands, and free of shell control syntax.\n- Do not start dev servers or perform dependency installation in verify.\n- Prefer tests, builds, smoke checks, or content assertions over file existence checks.\n- For Next.js, put package.json and app entrypoints before npm run build.\n\n- Do not add a final report step for normal success; report is only for explicit blockers.\n- In a fresh create/scaffold workspace, start with setup/implement work that owns an artifact instead of an empty inspect wrapper.\n- Keep verify-only steps connected to prior artifacts through the verify command or step instruction.\n\nReturn only one JSON object with top-level goal and steps. Do not use markdown fences.\nGoal: Build a Next.js game app" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "488b6143fd3be602c51f21fc81ce575ba481c4aacbcfa591c9e1ec23421567dd", + "user_body": "Goal: Build a Next.js game app\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"make-app\",\"original_step_index\":0,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Build a Next.js game app\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"make-app\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Create package.json and src/app/page.tsx for the game app\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\",\"src/app/page.tsx\"],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Build a Next.js game app\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"make-app\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Create package.json and src/app/page.tsx for the game app\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\",\"src/app/page.tsx\"],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Build a Next.js game app\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"make-app\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\",\"src/app/page.tsx\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Build a Next.js game app\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"make-app\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Create package.json and src/app/page.tsx for the game app\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\",\"src/app/page.tsx\"],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "last_valid_cleared_by_formation_retry", + "validated": [] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-refusals.json b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-refusals.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..72357a04 --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-refusals.json @@ -0,0 +1,797 @@ +[ + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "8d35344f03100a0891ed6cfa38562e2b8b4764d9fce9b08878d97746c6ad6b8e", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "three_weak", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "4a9da1e458516bb26344e087245e5dfa2a7f52ae152e2606d5459e580bd8f3d0", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "condition", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "ee2c8e7a58a34abe327fd3964746139a476af5c912761c19d1bd6548850d0c7e", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/other.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "target", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "6be3593120c1b98729f421751be3500ae187768786b17433d64519eab521bd27", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('changed')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "stdout", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "0afd3d6f456c100c3a46bfd8e179e26d42faf48257ef75f077ff3a77dd7661b5", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"ignored primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "message", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner README.md: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner README.md", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "94b7bcc21f490be3aa63a04473d4f0c10bd5d020f76118f16f1a92a1e06ca0d5", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner README.md\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "output", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: owner application of src/app/page.tsx lost original requirements/expected result from application; unrelated owners cannot discharge this duty: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: owner application of src/app/page.tsx lost original requirements/expected result from application; unrelated owners cannot discharge this duty", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "1e21bee25b6e4bdeeedc4669e8c4520599731caef73034396edc3e3b5c3052ca", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: owner application of src/app/page.tsx lost original requirements/expected result from application; unrelated owners cannot discharge this duty\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Ignore the original marker request.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "model_owner", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner package.json: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner package.json", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "6bbfd40014662e90f36de53b3965f61d885c3be656556566bb9af0f0e5316615", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner package.json\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Verify the profile-owned package_manifest contract by running every declared check and report any exact failure.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"unrelated-host\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"notes.txt\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "host_owner", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original instruction/expected result for check-markers: \"Check the saved source markers.\": Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original instruction/expected result for check-markers: \"Check the saved source markers.\"", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "da753be3368a48a7d1c50f2c8745394d5c2794e2934a0a11db298d1fb01a13fc", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original instruction/expected result for check-markers: \"Check the saved source markers.\"\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"fail\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "expected_result", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner package.json: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner package.json", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "44cbe55efb0f227f8fa6f6f6ff8dfd6fd007a8f536880ca8295b8f07dd1858f8", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation dropped original required output owner package.json\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Verify the profile-owned package_manifest contract by running every declared check and report any exact failure.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "owner_order", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "ecadb98c322fab50b4767b41618f7657db8d155211bfce0cf860bae5039ea3f5", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "condition_order", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: npm run build; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: npm run build; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "f947df7c6fe27ff28270ef3ce99432e91887eca21f6a1cf95e5d93aa8426bfae", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: npm run build; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "other_check", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "8f62c8494c9d11816acc4d666948de62b61658f84ff4b80afc7196344e732e22", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); process.exit(0);console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "success_override", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "251e5052d8634cd6d45a1336e9fc030a167bdcbfdd25beb6863bfbe764807ce6", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "d59cd692d95f88ecec4ea8ed6a0497de3eca10e635f222439c89c1cdcec29529", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: formation lost original check/expected result or its complete scope and boundary: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"; keep it on the complete owner or a Verify after all corresponding output owners\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "unknown_regex", + "validated": [] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 2, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 1, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + }, + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 3, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 0, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "exhausted" + } + ], + "error": "verifier plan admission exhausted existing 3-attempt planner budget: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: literal-marker replacement must explicitly preserve the predicates, stdout and failure propagation without shell wrappers: Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: literal-marker replacement must explicitly preserve the predicates, stdout and failure propagation without shell wrappers", + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 3, + "request_sha256": "9ce5ccc5150c7b79b3602e821012c0b17fc9217aafc6e034035debacace77212", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 2/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: literal-marker replacement must explicitly preserve the predicates, stdout and failure propagation without shell wrappers\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": null, + "series": "shell_override", + "validated": [] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-success.json b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-success.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b089ea2a --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/planner-success.json @@ -0,0 +1,413 @@ +[ + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + } + ], + "error": null, + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "8e12548892c2eabe7de42d0e7371ed3881a6df62095853dcc8b1d96bd7784b64", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": { + "goal": "Verify saved source markers", + "steps": [ + { + "expected_paths": [ + "src/app/page.tsx", + "README.md" + ], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "application", + "instruction": "Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.", + "kind": "implement", + "verify": [] + }, + { + "expected_paths": [ + "package.json" + ], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "configuration", + "instruction": "Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).", + "kind": "implement", + "verify": [ + "node -p \"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\"", + "node -p \"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\"", + "node -p \"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\"" + ] + }, + { + "expected_paths": [], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "check-markers", + "instruction": "Check the saved source markers.", + "kind": "verify", + "verify": [ + "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "npm run build" + ] + } + ] + }, + "series": "O", + "validated": [ + { + "replacements": [ + { + "expected_result": "pass", + "literal_markers": { + "expected_result": "pass", + "normalized_command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "original_command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "original_step": "check-markers", + "original_step_index": 2, + "predicates": { + "checks": [ + [ + "data-anvil-action=\"primary\"", + "missing primary" + ], + [ + "data-anvil-action=\"input\"", + "missing input" + ], + [ + "data-anvil-state", + "missing state" + ], + [ + "JSON.stringify", + "missing JSON snapshot" + ] + ], + "stdout": "ok", + "target": "src/app/page.tsx" + } + }, + "original_command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "reason": "identical_file_ordered_literal_predicates_and_output_without_catch", + "replacement_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"" + } + ], + "scope_preserved": true, + "trusted_contract": { + "deferred_verify_requirements": [], + "deterministic_oracles": [], + "evidence_hint_tokens": [ + "verify", + "saved", + "source", + "markers" + ], + "goal": "Verify saved source markers", + "profile": "nextjs", + "protected_paths": [], + "required_capabilities": [], + "required_evidence": [ + "requested_content_evidence" + ], + "required_obligations": [], + "required_paths": [ + "README.md", + "src/app/page.tsx" + ], + "verify_commands": [], + "verify_repair_cap": 2 + }, + "trusted_contract_sha256": "1efb37b775a989da3dc59ff3467e4d858e6bea640d72a6c13487b96f240266a8" + } + ] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + } + ], + "error": null, + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "7e7ba0bf49136f53d8abba1c4618c7d9165b985037f9f39a7176382cab378527", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\"); console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": { + "goal": "Verify saved source markers", + "steps": [ + { + "expected_paths": [ + "src/app/page.tsx", + "README.md" + ], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "application", + "instruction": "Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.", + "kind": "implement", + "verify": [] + }, + { + "expected_paths": [ + "package.json" + ], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "configuration", + "instruction": "Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).", + "kind": "implement", + "verify": [ + "node -p \"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\"", + "node -p \"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\"", + "node -p \"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\"" + ] + }, + { + "expected_paths": [], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "check-markers", + "instruction": "Check the saved source markers.", + "kind": "verify", + "verify": [ + "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "npm run build" + ] + } + ] + }, + "series": "V1", + "validated": [ + { + "replacements": [ + { + "expected_result": "pass", + "literal_markers": { + "expected_result": "pass", + "normalized_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "original_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "original_step": "check-markers", + "original_step_index": 2, + "predicates": { + "checks": [ + [ + "data-anvil-action=\"primary\"", + "missing primary" + ], + [ + "data-anvil-action=\"input\"", + "missing input" + ], + [ + "data-anvil-state", + "missing state" + ], + [ + "JSON.stringify", + "missing JSON snapshot" + ] + ], + "stdout": "ok", + "target": "src/app/page.tsx" + } + }, + "original_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "reason": "identical_file_ordered_literal_predicates_and_output_without_catch", + "replacement_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"" + } + ], + "scope_preserved": true, + "trusted_contract": { + "deferred_verify_requirements": [], + "deterministic_oracles": [], + "evidence_hint_tokens": [ + "verify", + "saved", + "source", + "markers" + ], + "goal": "Verify saved source markers", + "profile": "nextjs", + "protected_paths": [], + "required_capabilities": [], + "required_evidence": [ + "requested_content_evidence" + ], + "required_obligations": [], + "required_paths": [ + "README.md", + "src/app/page.tsx" + ], + "verify_commands": [], + "verify_repair_cap": 2 + }, + "trusted_contract_sha256": "1efb37b775a989da3dc59ff3467e4d858e6bea640d72a6c13487b96f240266a8" + } + ] + }, + { + "boundaries": [ + { + "event": "recovery_verifier_plan_admission", + "planner_attempt": 1, + "recovery_budget_changed": false, + "remaining_planner_attempts": 2, + "repair_attempt": null, + "status": "retry" + } + ], + "error": null, + "provider": "successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model", + "requests": [ + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 1, + "request_sha256": "9978e8a95da2b1b076bf3d600b5bd6596ea8f9953aa19e8a7fbe1f36e46d542f", + "user_body": "Create a step plan for this task:\nVerify saved source markers\n\nRequired final artifacts:\n- package.json\n- tsconfig.json\n- src/app/layout.tsx\n- src/app/page.tsx\n- src/app/global.d.ts\n\nProfile verification expectations:\n- Preferred deterministic verify commands:\n - npm run build\n- Order: Create package.json and a Next.js entrypoint before npm run build. Known-profile scaffolds are pre-provisioned before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend existing scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n- Do not use these in verify:\n - next dev\n - npm install\n - pnpm install\n - yarn install\n\n\nPre-provisioned scaffold note:\n- Required scaffold files are authored before phase 1 when absent; verify or extend the scaffold rather than re-planning file creation.\n\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\nInclude expected_paths on the final step so deterministic verification can catch missing artifacts." + }, + { + "message_count": 2, + "proposal_attempt": 2, + "request_sha256": "d36108963802d17dcfa578a0fbf6d4220d2d1a0d421e57a905605d753461b935", + "user_body": "Goal: Verify saved source markers\nCorrect this verifier plan admission failure (attempt 1/3): Recovery verifier binding ProposalRepairable: preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\": node_smoke_without_assertion (immutable_inline_evidence; app edits cannot strengthen this fixed verifier)\nPackage-script value displays require a fixed literal in saved original model/host obligations; a value absent from the command alone is not grounds for refusal. Use only the supplied saved-literal replacement, including strict comparison and original stdout. Dynamic properties, wrappers, ambiguous/conflicting or absent original literals are unsupported. Never infer expectations from artifacts or a later proposal.\nPreserve each original import target and pass result. Replace a pure import only with a target-specific check in this closed shape: node -e \"import('./original-path.js').then(actual=>{require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(actual.exportName,42)})\". Supply the actual required export/value, or actual.exportName(...[literal JSON arguments]) and a literal JSON expected result. Alternatively explicitly propose the sorted runtime export-name set using deepStrictEqual(Object.keys(actual).sort(),[literal JSON names]); an explicitly empty set can describe a type-only module. That alternative verifies loadability and runtime export boundary only, not interface fields or business behavior. Do not infer its expectation from a filename. Preserve all original instructions, outputs and owner order. No unrelated assertion, added check beside the weak original, catch or success override discharges it. Unsupported checks must be reproposed with preserved scope or stop within the current budget.\n\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n[{\"original_command\":\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"normalized_command\":\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"original_step\":\"check-markers\",\"original_step_index\":2,\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"predicates\":{\"target\":\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"checks\":[[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"\",\"missing primary\"],[\"data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"\",\"missing input\"],[\"data-anvil-state\",\"missing state\"],[\"JSON.stringify\",\"missing JSON snapshot\"]],\"stdout\":\"ok\"}}]\nReturn a complete StepPlan. Assign verifier creation to one dedicated Implement/pass per original producer; retain application/configuration work in separate owners. Preserve every original requirement verbatim within the responsible instructions, every required output, expected result and check; do not erase mixed duties. Host augmentation targets the last implementation step, so place the application/configuration owner last when needed. Keep model and host duties on their respective executable owners; do not duplicate the combined instruction.\nOriginal scope to preserve:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}\nOriginal obligation sources (model and host separately):\n{\"model\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]},\"host\":{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"For the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[]}]}}\nHost-augmented proposal:\n{\"goal\":\"Verify saved source markers\",\"steps\":[{\"id\":\"application\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.\",\"expected_paths\":[\"src/app/page.tsx\",\"README.md\"],\"verify\":[]},{\"id\":\"configuration\",\"kind\":\"implement\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\\n\\nProfile contract:\\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\\\"restart\\\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).\",\"expected_paths\":[\"package.json\"],\"verify\":[\"node -p \\\"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\",\"node -p \\\"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\\\"\"]},{\"id\":\"check-markers\",\"kind\":\"verify\",\"expected_result\":\"pass\",\"instruction\":\"Check the saved source markers.\",\"expected_paths\":[],\"verify\":[\"node -e \\\"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"primary\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing primary\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\\\\\"input\\\\\\\"'),\\\\\\\"missing input\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\\\\\"missing state\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\\\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\\\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\\\"\",\"npm run build\"]}]}" + } + ], + "returned_plan": { + "goal": "Verify saved source markers", + "steps": [ + { + "expected_paths": [ + "src/app/page.tsx", + "README.md" + ], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "application", + "instruction": "Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md.", + "kind": "implement", + "verify": [] + }, + { + "expected_paths": [ + "package.json" + ], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "configuration", + "instruction": "Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.\n\nProfile contract:\nFor the nextjs profile, create a runnable Next.js app, not only package metadata. Keep the project in the workspace root unless a project subdirectory already exists. Preserve the language and styling toolchains declared by an existing project. A JavaScript project using plain CSS requires package.json, an App Router page and layout, and the imported stylesheet; do not add TypeScript, @types, Tailwind, PostCSS, or Autoprefixer only to satisfy a template. A TypeScript project additionally requires a coherent tsconfig and type dependencies. If those mode-appropriate files are absent, write the coherent App Router scaffold before further inspection. package.json must include compatible next, react, and react-dom dependencies plus scripts.build = `next build`. If Tailwind is used, package.json must include tailwindcss/postcss/autoprefixer and postcss.config plugins must include BOTH tailwindcss and autoprefixer. For TypeScript/TSX apps, create tsconfig.json before treating the app as complete. Keep a single route-bound implementation; do not leave capability components unimported. Do not use deprecated moduleResolution=node10 or target=ES5; prefer moduleResolution=bundler and target=ES2017 or newer. For interactive UI, expose task-agnostic observability hooks: data-anvil-action=\"primary\" on the main start/submit/action control, data-anvil-action=\"input\" on the main text entry surface when one exists, and data-anvil-state containing JSON for meaningful visible state after each render. The data-anvil-state snapshot must include at least one dimension that immediately responds to input, such as the current selection or edited value. When the contract includes start_or_restart_flow, every restart affordance (including terminal and active states when present) should carry data-anvil-action=\"restart\"; the initial primary action alone cannot satisfy recovery verification. A restart reachable during active use (hook or keyboard shortcut) allows behavioral verification, while an overlay-only restart may verify as unverified:terminal_state_not_reached (partial). No explicit port was requested; use port 3011 for scripts.dev and scripts.start (`next dev -p 3011` and `next start -p 3011` or equivalent `--port 3011` forms).", + "kind": "implement", + "verify": [ + "node -p \"['dev'].every(function(k){return String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false}) ? true : process.exit(1)\"", + "node -p \"['start'].every(function(k){return Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k] ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='next' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})==k : false}) ? String(Object(require('./package.json').scripts)[k]).split(' ').some(function(t,i,a){return t=='--port=3011' ? true : t=='-p' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : t=='-p3011' ? true : t=='--port' ? a.slice(i+1).find(function(x){return x})=='3011' : false}) : false : true}) ? true : process.exit(1)\"", + "node -p \"String(require('./package.json').scripts.build)=='next build' ? true : process.exit(1)\"" + ] + }, + { + "expected_paths": [], + "expected_result": "pass", + "id": "check-markers", + "instruction": "Check the saved source markers.", + "kind": "verify", + "verify": [ + "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "npm run build" + ] + } + ] + }, + "series": "SWALLOW", + "validated": [ + { + "replacements": [ + { + "expected_result": "pass", + "literal_markers": { + "expected_result": "pass", + "normalized_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "original_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "original_step": "check-markers", + "original_step_index": 2, + "predicates": { + "checks": [ + [ + "data-anvil-action=\"primary\"", + "missing primary" + ], + [ + "data-anvil-action=\"input\"", + "missing input" + ], + [ + "data-anvil-state", + "missing state" + ], + [ + "JSON.stringify", + "missing JSON snapshot" + ] + ], + "stdout": "ok", + "target": "src/app/page.tsx" + } + }, + "original_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "reason": "identical_file_ordered_literal_predicates_and_output_without_catch", + "replacement_command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"" + } + ], + "scope_preserved": true, + "trusted_contract": { + "deferred_verify_requirements": [], + "deterministic_oracles": [], + "evidence_hint_tokens": [ + "verify", + "saved", + "source", + "markers" + ], + "goal": "Verify saved source markers", + "profile": "nextjs", + "protected_paths": [], + "required_capabilities": [], + "required_evidence": [ + "requested_content_evidence" + ], + "required_obligations": [], + "required_paths": [ + "README.md", + "src/app/page.tsx" + ], + "verify_commands": [], + "verify_repair_cap": 2 + }, + "trusted_contract_sha256": "1efb37b775a989da3dc59ff3467e4d858e6bea640d72a6c13487b96f240266a8" + } + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/dev-reports/issue-488/verification.md b/dev-reports/issue-488/verification.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..6b8c7955 --- /dev/null +++ b/dev-reports/issue-488/verification.md @@ -0,0 +1,127 @@ +# Issue #488 verification + +- Status: `passed` + +All required checks below completed successfully after the corrections recorded +in the intermediate-failures section. The full suite ran outside the sandbox +because its existing local HTTP tests require listeners. +Environment: macOS/aarch64, Node `v24.1.0`, rustc `1.94.0`, cargo `1.94.0`. +Tests use real local Node processes and communication-success mock providers. +No live model API or browser experiment was used. + +## Checks + +- `ISSUE488_NODE_EVIDENCE=dev-reports/issue-488/node-observations.json ISSUE488_PLANNER_EVIDENCE=dev-reports/issue-488 cargo test issue488 --lib`: `passed` +- `cargo test recovery_step_plan_binding --lib`: `passed` +- `cargo test --test corpus_regression`: `passed` +- `cargo test --test protection_coverage_audit --test generality_guardrails`: `passed` +- `cargo fmt --all -- --check`: `passed` +- `cargo clippy --all-targets -- -D warnings`: `passed` +- `cargo test`: `passed` +- `git diff --check`: `passed` + +Focused: 12 tests, including 24 real Node/direct/shell/Verify cases, 24 actual +final-executor cases, 24 registration batches and four mock series. Related +binding tests: 53; corpus: 7; generality guardrails: 10; protection audit: 2. +Each command exited 0. The full suite completed unit, integration and doc tests: +2976 passed / 0 failed / 42 ignored across top-level targets (nested subprocess +results are not double-counted). Its unit result was 2624 passed / 0 failed / +19 ignored. Existing ignored tests +retain their defaults; no ignored/live/PTY test is claimed as executed. +The pre-production baseline reproduction passed one test, as recorded in +design.md; its baseline-only expectation was subsequently updated to the +corrected behavior rather than left as a failing regression. + +Final raw local logs (not committed): `/tmp/issue488-focused-final.log`, +`/tmp/issue488-related-final.log`, `/tmp/issue488-corpus-final.log`, +`/tmp/issue488-audits-final.log`, `/tmp/issue488-clippy-final.log`, +`/tmp/issue488-cargo-test-complete.log`. Corpus fixture hashes and all four +command SHA256 values were also checked against source-manifest.json and the +saved Issue command values. Captured JSON was regenerated with the corrected +argv observation names and original→replacement/trusted-contract records. + +## Intermediate failures and corrections + +- Initial test compilation used the wrong deferred-requirement argument type; + subsequent test additions had missing imports/wrong CompileError fields. These + were test compilation errors, corrected without changing product contracts. +- Initial policy controls incorrectly assumed curl/rm/nonliteral Node spellings + were rejected by this baseline, and that a compound containing inline JS was + safely splittable. Inspected existing normalization; now test a known rejected + parent-traversal command, preserve nonliteral behavior and use a supported + simple compound. No allowance was added to satisfy the test. +- An unknown obligation is rejected by contract validation before formation; + the test now distinguishes that rejection from the new gate predicate. +- Initial setup-fallback test took deterministic scaffold generation before any + mock request. Corrected the invocation to reach the actual fallback after three + mock replies. Added actual last-valid return and formation-Retry-clearing cases + following parent review; direct finish tests remain separately identified. +- A shell success wrapper was erased by existing normalization. Added raw proposal + validation for the new finite rewrite, consistent with #484, then its refusal + test passed. +- First corpus run: 6 passed / 1 failed because its lightweight parser interpreted + a quoted fixture key literally. Changed the new expectation key to existing + corpus syntax; no detector/acceptance expectation was weakened. +- First clippy run reported two needless test borrows/clones; corrected them. +- Parent review corrected an overstrong argv observation field. Saved evidence + now states classifier_parser_argv and shell_and_direct_outcomes_match, with no + claim of observing shell-process argv. +- The sandbox full-suite attempt failed local HTTP listeners with `Operation not + permitted`; five tests then remained waiting. Terminated only that invocation + and its confirmed child test process. This attempt is not counted as passed. + Raw log: `/tmp/issue488-cargo-test.log`. +- The first outside-sandbox full suite passed all unit tests (2624 passed, 19 + ignored), then failed `nextjs_boundary_erosion_tripwire_keeps_dispatch_sites_audited` + (generality guardrails: 9 passed, 1 failed; cargo exit 101). The new registration + helper had two direct Next.js literal comparisons, and the new final-acceptance + test file lacked the existing scanner's local cfg(test) module convention. + Reused `profile::is_nextjs_profile` for both predicates and wrapped the test file + in `#[cfg(test)] mod tests`, following existing final-acceptance tests. No + guardrail expectation, baseline or scanner was changed. Focused guardrails now + pass 10/10. Raw failed log: `/tmp/issue488-cargo-test-unsandboxed.log`. +- The next outside-sandbox full suite reached `protection_coverage_audit` and + failed its normalization-boundary rule on a new test's direct + `validate_verify_command` call (1 passed, 1 failed; cargo exit 101). That rule + scans both production and test files without a cfg(test) exclusion. The control + now calls `normalize_verify_command` (the same implementation used by + `validate_verify_command`) and asserts the exact retained spelling. No policy, + audit exception or test expectation was relaxed. Raw failed log: + `/tmp/issue488-cargo-test-final.log`. + + +## Acceptance criteria trace + +Test names below omit their module prefix. All new tests are selected by +`cargo test issue488 --lib`; related existing tests are selected by +`cargo test recovery_step_plan_binding --lib` and the full suite. + +| AC | Evidence and scope | +| --- | --- | +| 1. Baseline/version/gap | design.md records the pre-production dynamic test: O/V1/SWALLOW already Retry in Admission, direct StepPlan registration still succeeded, final static gate failed; V2 passed, but O/V1/SWALLOW→V2 rewrites were refused. `issue488_real_formation_registration_and_final_boundary` locks the corrected behavior. #479/#484 commits are already ancestors; no predecessor branch was assumed or imported. | +| 2. Exact commands/fixtures | `tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/{commands,contract,matrix,source-manifest}.json`, normal + four omission fixtures + missing file. Per-command hashes match the Issue and immutable historical command input. `issue488_real_node_matrix_preserves_classification_and_failure_observations` consumes 24 cases. `node-observations.json` saves exit, stdout, stderr hash/failure excerpt and classifier-parser argv supplied to direct Node. It asserts shell/direct outcomes match; shell argv itself is not observed. README describes #479/#484 corpus differences. | +| 3. Narrow scope + broad prior refusal | `issue488_authority_and_requirement_controls_preserve_existing_broad_formation`: configured, unowned, already registered, Config profile, contract profile, fix/investigate intent, empty requirements, unknown/normalized obligations, capability-only controls. Authority comes from Config + current-run provenance, never proposal goal/name. #466 nonexecuting-step/compound test covers candidate filtering; raw policy/profile filtering precedes the new guard. The 24-case matrix repeats Admission/registration with every source omission, showing file-independent classification. | +| 4. V2 and independent gates | `issue488_final_executor_keeps_weak_and_actual_command_failure_separate` runs actual final acceptance for all 24 cases using an explicitly generic profile to isolate command/evidence, and separately asserts the Next.js gate rejects the reduced non-app fixture. `issue488_other_requirements_compile_and_business_failure_remain_independent` executes an independent Node assertion over synthetic saved/reloaded data and passes the negative result to the existing behavior gate. No live app success, browser or build is claimed. Baseline has no separate source_verifier_admission module; parent WIP is not imported. | +| 5. Requirement-preserving rewrite | `issue488_mock_rewrite_accepts_full_requirements_and_records_mapping` admits O/V1/SWALLOW→V2 while preserving full model/host duties and all four ordered predicates. `issue488_mock_exhaustion_and_missing_duties_never_register_or_execute` consumes 15 refusal cases (condition, path, stdout, message, output, both owners, result, owner/check order, other check, added success exit, unknown regex, shell masking, repeated weak). Existing replacement event records original/normalized command, step/index, target/predicates/stdout and validated replacement. Saved mappings and trusted-contract snapshot/hash are in planner-success.json. | +| 6. Four mock series + real returns | planner-success.json, planner-refusals.json, planner-fallback.json and planner-last-valid.json capture actual last user request bodies, complete request hashes, returned plan/error, proposal count and boundary events. All replies are communication-success mocks. Success takes 2 proposals; repeated weak/omission takes 3, leaving a fourth reply unused; the execution client is untouched and contract bytes unchanged. `issue488_mock_fallback_rechecks_retained_scope_and_weak_candidate` reaches actual setup fallback; its direct finish checks are separately labelled. `issue488_driver_last_valid_return_and_formation_retry_clearing_are_observed` reaches quality→lint/schema→last-valid return and separately observes formation Retry clearing last_valid. Recovery budget flags remain false; no retry cap changes. | +| 7. Atomic registration | `issue488_each_registration_entry_is_atomic_in_both_orders_and_accepts_good_batch`: command, StepPlan/producer and empty handoff entry × O/V1/SWALLOW/all-good × both orders = 24 batches. 18 mixed batches reject with byte-identical contract/commands, unchanged producer obligations, no success event; 6 all-good batches succeed. | +| 8. Existing exclusions/authority | The authority test plus `issue488_policy_normalization_generated_hooks_and_closed_contracts_stay_separate` cover configured/unowned/registered/closed, other profile/intent, nonliteral classification, policy rejection, supported simple compound vs unsupported inline compound and generated hooks. Baseline nonliteral Node policy is not silently tightened or relaxed. #466/#479/#484 related tests cover existing broader restrictions and closed producer authority. | +| 9. Mixed failures/identity | `issue488_other_requirements_compile_and_business_failure_remain_independent` retains missing required evidence together with weak evidence, then adds a labelled synthetic compiler observation without erasing either; synthetic business failure remains a separate behavior-gate failure. `issue488_contract_identity_is_checked_before_fixed_evidence_diagnosis` changes only frozen contract whitespace and verifies the independent contract-changed rejection for O and V2. No C5-specific routing is introduced or claimed. | +| 10. Verification | Final Checks section records focused, related, corpus, fmt, clippy and full cargo test exit results. No release-sensitive change: no release build/version check required. No Python harness change. | + +## Boundary/source notes + +Trusted run profile/intent use `Config::profile` and `resolved_run_intent`; +contract ownership is `begin_run` + `record_generated_contract`/`owns_run_contract`. +Configured-path detection and registered command membership prevent new authority +for closed checks. `admitted_final_success_commands` retains normal normalization, +command/path validation and artifact/profile filtering. The new helper feeds the +same `verify_command_kind` and `refresh_runtime_acceptance_report` used by final +acceptance, with an empty workspace to establish command-local classification. +Unknown obligation roles still fail contract validation; normalized roles and +empty requirement sets follow the existing final gate. + +The fully saved Issue body, C5 report/repair-spec/freeze/command input, independent +review and cause-report-D4 were read from the parent read-only workspace. No +historical artifacts or parent WIP were changed. Historical mixed C5 routing +observations are context, not measurements of this baseline. Curated evidence +contains mock bodies and test observations only; raw full-suite logs stay in /tmp. diff --git a/src/minimal_loop/evidence/command_diagnosis.rs b/src/minimal_loop/evidence/command_diagnosis.rs index ec3549a8..222fa06e 100644 --- a/src/minimal_loop/evidence/command_diagnosis.rs +++ b/src/minimal_loop/evidence/command_diagnosis.rs @@ -4,6 +4,36 @@ use super::{VerifyCommandKind, collect_workspace_evidence, verify_command_kind}; use serde::Serialize; use std::path::Path; +/// Run the final command classifier without application files, then the same +/// requirement normalization/pruning used by final acceptance. This is only a +/// preclosure refusal: it never grants evidence or substitutes for execution. +pub(crate) fn source_independent_inline_failure( + contract: &crate::minimal_loop::completion::CompletionContract, + command: &str, +) -> Option { + let words = super::verify_command_classification::single_command_words(command)?; + if words.first()?.as_str() != "node" { + return None; + } + super::verify_command_classification::inline_argument(&words[1..])?; + let super::VerifyCommandKind::Weak(reason) = + super::verify_command_kind(command, &super::WorkspaceEvidence::default()) + else { + return None; + }; + let mut report = super::RuntimeAcceptanceReport { + weak_evidence: vec![reason.clone()], + ..Default::default() + }; + super::refresh_runtime_acceptance_report( + &mut report, + &contract.required_capabilities, + &contract.required_evidence, + &contract.required_obligations, + ); + (!report.passed && report.weak_evidence.contains(&reason)).then_some(reason) +} + #[derive(Debug, Clone, Serialize)] pub(crate) struct Diagnosis { pub(crate) command: String, diff --git a/src/planner/final_acceptance/issue488_tests.rs b/src/planner/final_acceptance/issue488_tests.rs new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c43a1958 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/planner/final_acceptance/issue488_tests.rs @@ -0,0 +1,206 @@ +//! D4 final boundaries; generic profile isolates the actual final executor from +//! the separate Next.js build/browser gates. No synthetic app success is claimed. +#[cfg(test)] +mod tests { + use super::super::super::*; + use crate::planner::runner::final_acceptance::*; + use crate::planner::runner::{ + CompileError, ProfileBehaviorProbeReport, RuntimeAcceptanceReport, + final_acceptance_release_gate_with_runtime, mark_release_gate_profile_behavior_failed, + }; + use clap::Parser; + use serde_json::Value; + + fn fixture(name: &str) -> String { + std::fs::read_to_string( + Path::new(env!("CARGO_MANIFEST_DIR")) + .join("tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline") + .join(name), + ) + .unwrap() + } + fn command(name: &str) -> String { + let commands: Value = serde_json::from_str(&fixture("commands.json")).unwrap(); + commands[name]["command"].as_str().unwrap().into() + } + fn setup(root: &Path, name: &str, variant: &str) -> (Config, UltraPlan) { + std::fs::create_dir_all(root.join("src/app")).unwrap(); + if variant != "file_missing" { + std::fs::write( + root.join("src/app/page.tsx"), + fixture(&format!("fixtures/{variant}.txt")), + ) + .unwrap(); + } + std::fs::write(root.join("README.md"), "D4 marker fixture").unwrap(); + let mut contract: Value = serde_json::from_str(&fixture("contract.json")).unwrap(); + contract["profile"] = json!("generic"); + contract["verify_commands"] = json!([command(name)]); + std::fs::write(root.join("contract.json"), contract.to_string()).unwrap(); + let mut c = + Config::from_cli(crate::cli::Cli::parse_from(["commandagent", "--ux-demo"])).unwrap(); + c.workspace_root = root.into(); + c.profile = "generic".into(); + c.profile_explicit = true; + c.offline = true; + c.completion_contract_path = Some(root.join("contract.json")); + c.eval_events_path = Some(root.join("events.jsonl")); + let p = UltraPlan { + goal: "Verify saved source markers".into(), + profile: "generic".into(), + intent: "create".into(), + style: "balanced".into(), + phases: vec![], + }; + (c, p) + } + fn final_event(c: &Config) -> Value { + std::fs::read_to_string(c.eval_events_path.as_ref().unwrap()) + .unwrap() + .lines() + .filter_map(|line| serde_json::from_str::(line).ok()) + .rfind(|e| e["event"] == "ultra_final_acceptance") + .unwrap() + } + + #[test] + fn issue488_final_executor_keeps_weak_and_actual_command_failure_separate() { + for name in ["O", "V1", "V2", "SWALLOW"] { + for variant in [ + "normal", + "primary", + "input", + "state", + "snapshot", + "file_missing", + ] { + let root = tempfile::tempdir().unwrap(); + let (c, p) = setup(root.path(), name, variant); + let bytes = std::fs::read(root.path().join("contract.json")).unwrap(); + let report = ultra_final_acceptance_report(&p, &c).unwrap(); + assert_eq!( + report.is_pass(), + name == "V2" && variant == "normal", + "{name}/{variant}: {report:?}" + ); + let event = final_event(&c); + let d = &event["command_diagnoses"][0]; + assert_eq!(d["kind"], if name == "V2" { "test" } else { "weak" }); + let command_failed = + variant == "file_missing" || variant != "normal" && name != "SWALLOW"; + assert_eq!( + report + .command_failures + .iter() + .any(|f| f.command == command(name)), + command_failed + ); + assert_eq!(d["execution_failure"].is_string(), command_failed); + assert_eq!( + std::fs::read(root.path().join("contract.json")).unwrap(), + bytes + ); + // A Test classification cannot bypass the independent Next.js gate. + let profile = + crate::planner::profile::verify_profile(root.path(), "nextjs", &p.goal); + assert!(!profile.is_pass()); + } + } + } + + #[test] + fn issue488_other_requirements_compile_and_business_failure_remain_independent() { + let root = tempfile::tempdir().unwrap(); + let (c, p) = setup(root.path(), "O", "normal"); + let path = root.path().join("contract.json"); + let mut contract: Value = serde_json::from_slice(&std::fs::read(&path).unwrap()).unwrap(); + contract["required_evidence"] = + json!(["requested_content_evidence", "stateful_update_evidence"]); + std::fs::write(&path, contract.to_string()).unwrap(); + let mut report = ultra_final_acceptance_report(&p, &c).unwrap(); + let event = final_event(&c); + assert!( + event["missing_evidence"] + .as_array() + .unwrap() + .iter() + .any(|v| v == "stateful_update_evidence") + ); + assert!( + event["weak_evidence"] + .as_array() + .unwrap() + .iter() + .any(|v| v == "node_smoke_without_assertion") + ); + // A synthetic compiler observation tests the existing handoff boundary; + // the reduced text fixture is deliberately not built as an application. + report.push_compile_errors( + "npm run build", + vec![CompileError { + path: "src/app/page.tsx".into(), + line: 2, + column: 1, + excerpt: String::new(), + symbol: None, + route_bound: Some(true), + message: "Type string is not assignable to number".into(), + }], + ); + assert!(!report.is_pass()); + assert_eq!(report.compile_errors.len(), 1); + assert!(!report.profile_failures.is_empty()); + + let other = tempfile::tempdir().unwrap(); + let (c, p) = setup(other.path(), "V2", "normal"); + assert!(ultra_final_acceptance_report(&p, &c).unwrap().is_pass()); + let observations: Value = serde_json::from_str(&fixture("business-controls.json")).unwrap(); + for positive in [true, false] { + let actual = &observations[if positive { "positive" } else { "negative" }]; + std::fs::write(other.path().join("observed.json"), actual.to_string()).unwrap(); + let oracle = "node -e \"require('node:assert/strict').deepStrictEqual(require('./observed.json'),{saved:true,reloaded:true})\""; + let check = crate::planner::step_plan::PlanStep { + id: "independent-oracle".into(), + kind: "verify".into(), + expected_result: "pass".into(), + instruction: "Assert synthetic observations".into(), + expected_paths: vec![], + verify: vec![oracle.into()], + }; + let oracle_report = crate::planner::verify::verify_step(other.path(), &check); + assert_eq!(oracle_report.is_pass(), positive); + let runtime = resolve_profile_runtime("generic"); + let acceptance = RuntimeAcceptanceReport { + passed: true, + primary_reason: "pass".into(), + ..Default::default() + }; + let mut gate = final_acceptance_release_gate_with_runtime( + &c, + runtime, + &p.goal, + &[], + Some(&acceptance), + false, + ); + if !oracle_report.is_pass() { + mark_release_gate_profile_behavior_failed( + &mut gate, + &ProfileBehaviorProbeReport { + status: "failed", + reasons: vec!["synthetic_saved_reload_oracle_failed".into()], + evidence_path: Some("observed.json".into()), + }, + ); + } + assert_eq!(gate.status == "pass", positive); + if !positive { + assert!( + gate.reasons + .iter() + .any(|r| r.contains("synthetic_saved_reload_oracle_failed")) + ); + } + } + } +} diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority.rs b/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority.rs index e4f7ed79..b021d25f 100644 --- a/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority.rs +++ b/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority.rs @@ -7,6 +7,7 @@ use sha2::{Digest, Sha256}; use crate::config::Config; use crate::minimal_loop::completion::CompletionContract; +pub(crate) mod inline_admission; mod local_script; #[path = "recovery_contract_authority/provenance.rs"] mod provenance; @@ -121,9 +122,9 @@ pub(crate) fn register_step_plan_commands( let original = contract.verify_commands.clone(); let profile = contract.profile.as_deref().unwrap_or_default(); let goal = contract.goal.as_deref().unwrap_or_default(); - contract - .verify_commands - .extend(admitted_final_success_commands(profile, goal, commands)?); + let admitted = admitted_final_success_commands(profile, goal, commands)?; + inline_admission::validate(config, &contract, &admitted)?; + contract.verify_commands.extend(admitted); let contract = contract.validate(&config.workspace_root)?; if contract.verify_commands != original { persist_generated_commands(config, &path, &contract, "admitted_step_plan")?; @@ -244,14 +245,17 @@ fn complete_generated_verify_commands( } let goal = contract.goal.as_deref().unwrap_or_default(); - contract.verify_commands = - admitted_final_success_commands(&profile, goal, failed_plan_verify_commands)?; + let admitted = admitted_final_success_commands(&profile, goal, failed_plan_verify_commands)?; + inline_admission::validate(config, &contract, &admitted)?; + contract.verify_commands = admitted; let source = if contract.verify_commands.is_empty() { - contract.verify_commands = profile_commands( + let preferred = profile_commands( config, &profile, contract.goal.as_deref().unwrap_or_default(), ); + inline_admission::validate(config, &contract, &preferred)?; + contract.verify_commands = preferred; "profile_runtime" } else { "failed_plan_handoff" diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/inline_admission.rs b/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/inline_admission.rs new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e2d7959a --- /dev/null +++ b/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/inline_admission.rs @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +//! Preclosure candidate validation. No command removal, replacement or writes. +use super::*; + +pub(crate) fn eligible(config: &Config, contract: &CompletionContract) -> anyhow::Result { + Ok(crate::planner::profile::is_nextjs_profile(&config.profile) + && config.resolved_run_intent() == crate::config::IntentId::Create + && contract + .profile + .as_deref() + .is_some_and(crate::planner::profile::is_nextjs_profile) + && CompletionContract::configured_path_for_config(config)?.is_none() + && provenance::owns_run_contract(&generated_path(config, ULTRA_RUN_CONTRACT))) +} + +pub(crate) fn refusal( + config: &Config, + contract: &CompletionContract, + command: &str, +) -> anyhow::Result> { + if !eligible(config, contract)? || contract.verify_commands.iter().any(|c| c == command) { + return Ok(None); + } + Ok( + crate::minimal_loop::evidence::command_diagnosis::source_independent_inline_failure( + contract, command, + ), + ) +} + +/// Call with the complete normalized, policy-checked, profile-filtered batch +/// before persisting either contract bytes or verifier producer obligations. +pub(crate) fn validate( + config: &Config, + contract: &CompletionContract, + commands: &[String], +) -> anyhow::Result<()> { + for command in commands { + if let Some(reason) = refusal(config, contract, command)? { + anyhow::bail!( + "preclosure weak inline verification requires formation: {command}: {reason}; the current classifier cannot recognize this failure path; re-propose with all original requirements preserved before registration" + ); + } + } + Ok(()) +} diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/verifier_obligations.rs b/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/verifier_obligations.rs index a513839a..2bb1dd37 100644 --- a/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/verifier_obligations.rs +++ b/src/planner/recovery_contract_authority/verifier_obligations.rs @@ -50,9 +50,9 @@ pub(crate) fn register(config: &Config, plan: &StepPlan) -> anyhow::Result<()> { return Ok(()); } let original_contract = contract.clone(); - contract - .verify_commands - .extend(admitted_commands(config, &contract, plan)?); + let admitted = admitted_commands(config, &contract, plan)?; + super::inline_admission::validate(config, &contract, &admitted)?; + contract.verify_commands.extend(admitted); let scripts = scripts(&contract.verify_commands); let mut registered = provenance::verifier_steps(config); for step in &plan.steps { diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding.rs index 6cc7945d..4de64bd7 100644 --- a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding.rs +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding.rs @@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ pub(crate) mod admission; pub(crate) mod formation_scope; #[cfg(test)] mod issue466_tests; +mod literal_marker_formation; pub(crate) mod package_owner_scope; mod package_script_formation; pub(crate) mod profile_augmentation; diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/admission.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/admission.rs index 20bec8c2..4b6fea1b 100644 --- a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/admission.rs +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/admission.rs @@ -16,6 +16,7 @@ pub(crate) struct Admission { package_scripts: Option, awaiting_check: bool, duplicate_strengthen: bool, + marker_checks: Vec, } pub(crate) enum Decision { @@ -44,8 +45,12 @@ impl Admission { fn preserve(&self, plan: &StepPlan) -> anyhow::Result<()> { super::verifier_formation::preserve_registered(&self.replacements, plan)?; if let Some(original) = &self.original { - let (projected, _) = - super::verifier_formation::project(original, plan, self.package_scripts.as_ref()); + let (projected, _) = super::verifier_formation::project( + original, + plan, + self.package_scripts.as_ref(), + &self.marker_checks, + ); if let Some(sources) = &self.sources { sources.preserve(original, &projected)?; } else { @@ -57,6 +62,7 @@ impl Admission { fn retain(&mut self, config: &Config, plan: &StepPlan, contract: &CompletionContract) { if self.original.is_none() { + self.marker_checks = super::literal_marker_formation::capture(config, contract, plan); self.sources = Some(FormationScope::capture( plan, self.profile_addition.as_ref(), @@ -82,6 +88,17 @@ impl Admission { plan: StepPlan, ) -> anyhow::Result { self.require_capture_boundary()?; + if let Some(contract) = + crate::planner::recovery_contract_authority::load_for_handoff(config)? + && crate::planner::recovery_contract_authority::inline_admission::eligible( + config, &contract, + )? + { + let admitted = scope::admitted_commands(config, &contract, &plan)?; + crate::planner::recovery_contract_authority::inline_admission::validate( + config, &contract, &admitted, + )?; + } if let Some(original) = &self.original && let Err(error) = self.preserve(&plan) { @@ -131,6 +148,12 @@ impl Admission { self.package_scripts .as_ref() .map_or(Ok(()), |p| p.preserve_raw_commands(model)) + .and_then(|()| { + super::literal_marker_formation::preserve_raw_commands( + &self.marker_checks, + model, + ) + }) .and_then(|()| self.form(config, plan)) .map(|()| false) }; @@ -198,8 +221,12 @@ impl Admission { } self.preserve(plan)?; if let Some(original) = &self.original { - let (_, replacements) = - super::verifier_formation::project(original, plan, self.package_scripts.as_ref()); + let (_, replacements) = super::verifier_formation::project( + original, + plan, + self.package_scripts.as_ref(), + &self.marker_checks, + ); for replacement in replacements { if !self.replacements.contains(&replacement) { self.replacements.push(replacement); @@ -223,11 +250,14 @@ impl Admission { super::verifier_formation::require_formed(config, &scope::commands(plan)) { self.retain(config, plan, ®istered_contract); - let guidance = self + let mut guidance = self .package_scripts .as_ref() .map(|p| p.guidance()) .unwrap_or_default(); + guidance.push_str(&super::literal_marker_formation::guidance( + &self.marker_checks, + )); return if guidance.is_empty() { Err(error) } else { @@ -236,8 +266,12 @@ impl Admission { }; } if let Some(original) = &self.original { - let (_, replacements) = - super::verifier_formation::project(original, plan, self.package_scripts.as_ref()); + let (_, replacements) = super::verifier_formation::project( + original, + plan, + self.package_scripts.as_ref(), + &self.marker_checks, + ); crate::eval_events::emit( config.eval_events_path.as_deref(), json!({ diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue466_tests.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue466_tests.rs index 49ba14bf..2c980b41 100644 --- a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue466_tests.rs +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue466_tests.rs @@ -168,3 +168,6 @@ mod issue479; #[path = "issue484_tests.rs"] mod issue484; + +#[path = "issue488_tests.rs"] +mod issue488; diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue484_tests.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue484_tests.rs index 57fe36a3..aec81aa1 100644 --- a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue484_tests.rs +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue484_tests.rs @@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ fn issue484_saved_runner_forms_exact_literal_and_records_both_sources() { let after = saved(true); // Control for the pre-fix equivalence path: pure-import projection cannot // discharge this saved value display, even though the candidate is valid. - let (unformed, records) = super::super::verifier_formation::project(&before, &after, None); + let (unformed, records) = super::super::verifier_formation::project(&before, &after, None, &[]); assert!(records.is_empty()); assert!(admission::preserve(&before, &unformed).is_err()); let (result, client) = replay(&c, &before, &after); @@ -341,7 +341,7 @@ fn issue484_model_host_literals_are_checked_per_key_without_precedence() { after.steps[0].verify = vec![check()]; after.steps[0].instruction.push_str(&format!("\n{host}")); let (projected, records) = - super::super::verifier_formation::project(&before, &after, Some(&catalog)); + super::super::verifier_formation::project(&before, &after, Some(&catalog), &[]); assert_eq!(records.len(), usize::from(accepted)); assert_eq!(admission::preserve(&before, &projected).is_ok(), accepted); } diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_planner_tests.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_planner_tests.rs new file mode 100644 index 00000000..950b0f56 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_planner_tests.rs @@ -0,0 +1,414 @@ +use super::*; + +fn full_plan(name: &str) -> StepPlan { + let mut p = proposal_plan(name); + let mut app = step( + "application", + "implement", + &["src/app/page.tsx", "README.md"], + ); + app.instruction = + "Retain all four source marker conditions and document their text-only scope in README.md." + .into(); + let mut package = step("configuration", "implement", &["package.json"]); + package.instruction = "Preserve the package scripts and dependency versions.".into(); + p.steps.insert(0, app); + p.steps.insert(1, package); + p.steps[2].verify.push("npm run build".into()); + p +} + +fn replay( + c: &Config, + goal: &str, + replies: Vec, +) -> (anyhow::Result, Replay) { + let mut client = Replay::new(replies); + let result = crate::planner::runner::generate_step_plan_with_ui_for_phase( + &mut client, + goal, + c, + &crate::tui::NOOP_UI, + Some("core-implementation"), + true, + false, + ); + (result, client) +} + +fn audit( + label: &str, + c: &Config, + result: &anyhow::Result, + client: &Replay, +) -> serde_json::Value { + let requests = client.requests.lock().unwrap(); + let requests: Vec<_> = requests.iter().enumerate().map(|(i, messages)| json!({ + "proposal_attempt":i+1, + "request_sha256":format!("{:x}", Sha256::digest(serde_json::to_vec(messages).unwrap())), + "user_body":messages.iter().rfind(|m|m.role == "user").map(|m| &m.content), + "message_count":messages.len(), + })).collect(); + let boundaries: Vec<_> = events(c).into_iter().filter(|e| matches!(e["event"].as_str(), + Some("recovery_verifier_plan_admission" | "recovery_verifier_plan_return_rejected" | "planner_quality_retry" | "planner_quality_retry_degraded" | "planner_fallback_plan"))) + .map(|e| json!({"event":e["event"],"planner_attempt":e["planner_attempt"],"repair_attempt":e["repair_attempt"], + "status":e["status"],"remaining_planner_attempts":e["remaining_planner_attempts"],"recovery_budget_changed":e["recovery_budget_changed"]})).collect(); + let validated: Vec<_> = events(c) + .into_iter() + .filter(|e| e["event"] == "preclosure_verifier_replacements_validated") + .map(|e| { + json!({"replacements":e["replacements"], + "trusted_contract":e["package_script_formation"]["registered_contract"], + "trusted_contract_sha256":e["package_script_formation"]["registered_contract_sha256"], + "scope_preserved":e["scope_preserved"]}) + }) + .collect(); + json!({"series":label, "requests":requests, "validated":validated, + "returned_plan":result.as_ref().ok(), "error":result.as_ref().err().map(|e| format!("{e:#}")), + "boundaries":boundaries, "provider":"successful offline mock replies; no network retry or live model"}) +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_mock_rewrite_accepts_full_requirements_and_records_mapping() { + let mut audits = Vec::new(); + for name in ["O", "V1", "SWALLOW"] { + let (_root, c, _guard, path) = setup(); + let before = full_plan(name); + let after = full_plan("V2"); + let bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + let (result, client) = replay( + &c, + &before.goal, + vec![proposal(&before), proposal(&after), proposal(&after)], + ); + audits.push(audit(name, &c, &result, &client)); + let formed = result.unwrap_or_else(|e| panic!("{name}: {e:#}\n{}", json!(events(&c)))); + assert_eq!(client.requests.lock().unwrap().len(), 2); + assert_eq!( + std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(), + bytes, + "planning must not register" + ); + assert_eq!(formed.steps[0], after.steps[0]); + assert_eq!(formed.steps[2], after.steps[2]); + assert!( + formed.steps[1] + .instruction + .contains(&after.steps[1].instruction) + ); + let log = events(&c); + let refusal = log + .iter() + .find(|e| e["event"] == "recovery_verifier_plan_admission") + .unwrap(); + let host = refusal["original_obligation_sources"]["host"]["steps"][0]["instruction"] + .as_str() + .unwrap(); + assert!(formed.steps[1].instruction.contains(host)); + let requests = client.requests.lock().unwrap(); + let feedback = requests[1] + .iter() + .map(|m| m.content.as_str()) + .collect::>() + .join("\n"); + assert!(feedback.contains("current classifier cannot recognize")); + assert!(feedback.contains(&serde_json::to_string(&before.steps[2].verify[0]).unwrap())); + for step in &before.steps { + assert!(feedback.contains(&step.instruction)); + } + assert!(feedback.contains(serde_json::to_string(host).unwrap().trim_matches('"'))); + let record = log + .iter() + .find(|e| e["event"] == "preclosure_verifier_replacements_validated") + .unwrap(); + let mapping = &record["replacements"][0]; + assert_eq!(mapping["original_command"], command(name)); + assert_eq!(mapping["replacement_command"], command("V2")); + assert_eq!(mapping["literal_markers"]["original_step"], "check-markers"); + assert_eq!( + mapping["literal_markers"]["predicates"]["checks"] + .as_array() + .unwrap() + .len(), + 4 + ); + assert_eq!(refusal["recovery_budget_changed"], false); + scope::register(&c, &formed).unwrap(); + let contract = authority::load_for_handoff(&c).unwrap().unwrap(); + assert!(contract.verify_commands.contains(&command("V2"))); + assert!(!contract.verify_commands.contains(&command(name))); + } + if let Ok(dir) = std::env::var("ISSUE488_PLANNER_EVIDENCE") { + std::fs::write( + Path::new(&dir).join("planner-success.json"), + serde_json::to_vec_pretty(&audits).unwrap(), + ) + .unwrap(); + } +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_mock_exhaustion_and_missing_duties_never_register_or_execute() { + let mut audits = Vec::new(); + let cases: Vec = serde_json::from_str(&fixture("refusals.json")).unwrap(); + for case in cases.iter().map(String::as_str) { + let (root, c, _guard, path) = setup(); + let mut before = full_plan("O"); + let mut after = full_plan("V2"); + match case { + "three_weak" => after = before.clone(), + "shell_override" => after.steps[2].verify[0] = format!("{} || true", command("V2")), + "condition" => { + after.steps[2].verify[0] = command("V2").replace( + " assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");", + "", + ) + } + "target" => { + after.steps[2].verify[0] = + command("V2").replace("src/app/page.tsx", "src/app/other.tsx") + } + "stdout" => { + after.steps[2].verify[0] = + command("V2").replace("console.log('ok')", "console.log('changed')") + } + "message" => { + after.steps[2].verify[0] = + command("V2").replace("missing primary", "ignored primary") + } + "output" => after.steps[0].expected_paths.pop().map(|_| ()).unwrap(), + "model_owner" => { + after.steps[0].instruction = "Ignore the original marker request.".into() + } + "host_owner" => { + let mut decoy = step("unrelated-host", "implement", &["notes.txt"]); + decoy.instruction = after.steps[1].instruction.clone(); + after.steps.insert(2, decoy); + } + "expected_result" => after.steps[2].expected_result = "fail".into(), + "owner_order" => after.steps.swap(0, 2), + "condition_order" => { + after.steps[2].verify[0] = command("V2") + .replace("primary", "TEMP") + .replace("input", "primary") + .replace("TEMP", "input") + } + "other_check" => { + after.steps[2].verify.pop(); + } + "success_override" => { + after.steps[2].verify[0] = + command("V2").replace("console.log('ok')", "process.exit(0);console.log('ok')") + } + "unknown_regex" => { + before.steps[2].verify[0] = + command("O").replace("JSON\\.stringify", "JSON.stringify") + } + _ => unreachable!(), + } + assert!( + case == "unknown_regex" || after != full_plan("V2"), + "mutation ineffective: {case}" + ); + let bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + let (result, client) = replay( + &c, + &before.goal, + vec![ + proposal(&before), + proposal(&after), + proposal(&after), + proposal(&full_plan("V2")), + ], + ); + audits.push(audit(case, &c, &result, &client)); + assert!(result.is_err(), "{case}: {result:?}"); + assert_eq!(client.requests.lock().unwrap().len(), 3, "{case}"); + let mut execution = Replay::default(); + let result = + result.and_then(|p| crate::planner::runner::run_step_plan(&mut execution, &p, &c)); + assert!(result.is_err()); + assert!(execution.requests.lock().unwrap().is_empty()); + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(path).unwrap(), bytes); + assert!(!root.path().join("notes.txt").exists()); + assert!( + events(&c) + .iter() + .filter(|e| e["event"] == "recovery_verifier_plan_admission") + .all(|e| e["recovery_budget_changed"] == false) + ); + assert!( + !events(&c) + .iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] == "recovery_generated_completion_contract_completed") + ); + } + if let Ok(dir) = std::env::var("ISSUE488_PLANNER_EVIDENCE") { + std::fs::write( + Path::new(&dir).join("planner-refusals.json"), + serde_json::to_vec_pretty(&audits).unwrap(), + ) + .unwrap(); + } +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_mock_fallback_rechecks_retained_scope_and_weak_candidate() { + let mut audits = Vec::new(); + for setup_fallback in [false, true] { + let (_root, c, _guard, path) = setup(); + let before = full_plan("O"); + let bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + let goal = if setup_fallback { + "Phase id: setup\nPhase task: scaffold the project" + } else { + &before.goal + }; + let mut client = Replay::new(vec![ + proposal(&before), + AssistantReply::text("{invalid"), + AssistantReply::text("{invalid"), + ]); + let result = crate::planner::runner::generate_step_plan(&mut client, goal, &c); + audits.push(audit( + if setup_fallback { + "setup_fallback" + } else { + "no_last_valid_plan" + }, + &c, + &result, + &client, + )); + assert!( + result.is_err(), + "setup={setup_fallback}: {result:?}\n{}", + json!(events(&c)) + ); + assert_eq!(client.requests.lock().unwrap().len(), 3); + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(path).unwrap(), bytes); + if setup_fallback { + assert!( + events(&c) + .iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] == "recovery_verifier_plan_return_rejected") + ); + } + // Every finish path also applies the candidate guard, including a + // pre-existing last-valid candidate without retained Admission state. + assert!( + admission::Admission::default() + .finish(&c, None, proposal_plan("O")) + .is_err() + ); + let mut admission = admission::Admission::default(); + let mut original = before.clone(); + admission.strengthen(&c, &mut original); + assert!(matches!( + admission + .check(&c, None, &before, &mut original, 1) + .unwrap(), + admission::Decision::Retry(_) + )); + assert!( + admission.finish(&c, None, full_plan("V2")).is_err(), + "fallback lacking captured host obligation" + ); + } + if let Ok(dir) = std::env::var("ISSUE488_PLANNER_EVIDENCE") { + std::fs::write( + Path::new(&dir).join("planner-fallback.json"), + serde_json::to_vec_pretty(&audits).unwrap(), + ) + .unwrap(); + } +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_driver_last_valid_return_and_formation_retry_clearing_are_observed() { + let mut audits = Vec::new(); + for formation_retry in [false, true] { + let (_root, c, _guard, path) = setup(); + let bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + let mut first = plan(vec![step( + "make-app", + "implement", + &["package.json", "src/app/page.tsx"], + )]); + first.goal = "Build a Next.js game app".into(); + first.steps[0].instruction = + "Create package.json and src/app/page.tsx for the game app".into(); + first.steps[0].verify = vec![command("V2")]; + let mut next = first.clone(); + if formation_retry { + next.steps[0].verify = vec![command("O")]; + } else { + next.steps[0].verify = vec!["node check.js | node check2.js".into()]; + } + let mut client = Replay::new(vec![ + proposal(&first), + proposal(&next), + AssistantReply::text("{invalid"), + ]); + let result = crate::planner::runner::generate_step_plan(&mut client, &first.goal, &c); + let log = events(&c); + assert_eq!( + client.requests.lock().unwrap().len(), + 3, + "{formation_retry}: {result:?}\n{}", + json!(log) + ); + assert!( + log.iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] == "planner_quality_retry" && e["repair_attempt"] == 1), + "{}", + json!(log) + ); + audits.push(audit( + if formation_retry { + "last_valid_cleared_by_formation_retry" + } else { + "last_valid_return_after_quality_then_lint_then_schema" + }, + &c, + &result, + &client, + )); + if formation_retry { + assert!( + result.is_err(), + "weak retry must clear prior last_valid_plan" + ); + assert!( + log.iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] == "recovery_verifier_plan_admission" + && e["planner_attempt"] == 2 + && e["status"] == "retry") + ); + } else { + let returned = result.unwrap(); + assert_eq!(returned.steps[0].id, "make-app"); + assert_eq!(returned.steps[0].verify, first.steps[0].verify); + assert!( + log.iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] == "planner_quality_retry_degraded") + ); + assert!( + !log.iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] == "recovery_verifier_plan_admission") + ); + // Check actual returned host duties as well as model duties. + let mut augmented = first.clone(); + admission::Admission::default().strengthen(&c, &mut augmented); + assert_eq!(returned, augmented); + } + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(path).unwrap(), bytes); + } + if let Ok(dir) = std::env::var("ISSUE488_PLANNER_EVIDENCE") { + std::fs::write( + Path::new(&dir).join("planner-last-valid.json"), + serde_json::to_vec_pretty(&audits).unwrap(), + ) + .unwrap(); + } +} diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_registration_tests.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_registration_tests.rs new file mode 100644 index 00000000..20c0d3d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_registration_tests.rs @@ -0,0 +1,238 @@ +use super::*; +use crate::planner::recovery_contract_authority::inline_admission; + +fn register(entry: &str, c: &Config, commands: &[String]) -> anyhow::Result<()> { + match entry { + "commands" => authority::register_step_plan_commands(c, commands), + "handoff" => authority::bind_for_recovery(c, commands).map(|_| ()), + "plan" => { + let mut p = proposal_plan("V2"); + p.steps[0].verify = commands.to_vec(); + let producer = step("make-verifier", "implement", &[SCRIPT]); + p.steps.insert(0, producer); + scope::register(c, &p) + } + _ => unreachable!(), + } +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_each_registration_entry_is_atomic_in_both_orders_and_accepts_good_batch() { + for entry in ["commands", "plan", "handoff"] { + for bad in [Some("O"), Some("V1"), Some("SWALLOW"), None] { + for reverse in [false, true] { + let (_root, c, _guard, path) = setup(); + let bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + let owners = scope::generated(&c); + let mut commands = vec![command("V2"), format!("node {SCRIPT}")]; + if let Some(bad) = bad { + commands.push(command(bad)); + } + if reverse { + commands.reverse(); + } + let result = register(entry, &c, &commands); + assert_eq!( + result.is_ok(), + bad.is_none(), + "{entry}/{bad:?}/{reverse}: {result:?}" + ); + if bad.is_some() { + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(), bytes); + assert_eq!(scope::generated(&c), owners); + assert!( + !events(&c) + .iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] + == "recovery_generated_completion_contract_completed") + ); + let stored: CompletionContract = serde_json::from_slice(&bytes).unwrap(); + assert!(stored.verify_commands.is_empty()); + } else { + let stored: CompletionContract = + serde_json::from_slice(&std::fs::read(path).unwrap()).unwrap(); + for command in &commands { + assert!(stored.verify_commands.contains(command)); + } + assert_eq!(scope::generated(&c).len(), usize::from(entry == "plan")); + assert!( + events(&c) + .iter() + .any(|e| e["event"] + == "recovery_generated_completion_contract_completed") + ); + } + } + } + } +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_authority_and_requirement_controls_preserve_existing_broad_formation() { + for control in [ + "eligible", + "configured", + "unowned", + "already_registered", + "config_profile", + "contract_profile", + "fix", + "investigate", + "empty_requirements", + "unknown_obligation", + "normalized_obligation", + "capability_only", + ] { + let (_root, mut c, guard, path) = setup(); + let mut guard = Some(guard); + let mut contract: CompletionContract = + serde_json::from_str(&fixture("contract.json")).unwrap(); + match control { + "configured" => c.completion_contract_path = Some(path.clone()), + "unowned" => drop(guard.take()), + "already_registered" => contract.verify_commands = vec![command("O")], + "config_profile" => c.profile = "generic".into(), + "contract_profile" => contract.profile = Some("generic".into()), + "fix" => c.intent_override = Some(crate::config::IntentId::Fix), + "investigate" => c.intent_override = Some(crate::config::IntentId::Investigate), + "empty_requirements" => contract.required_evidence.clear(), + "unknown_obligation" => { + contract.required_evidence.clear(); + contract.required_obligations = vec!["unknown".into()]; + } + "normalized_obligation" => { + contract.required_evidence.clear(); + contract.required_obligations = vec![" ACCEPTANCE-EVIDENCE ".into()]; + } + "capability_only" => { + contract.required_evidence.clear(); + contract.required_capabilities = vec!["input_output_contract".into()]; + } + _ => {} + } + std::fs::write(&path, serde_json::to_vec(&contract).unwrap()).unwrap(); + let refused = inline_admission::refusal(&c, &contract, &command("O")) + .unwrap() + .is_some(); + assert_eq!( + refused, + matches!( + control, + "eligible" | "normalized_obligation" | "capability_only" + ), + "{control}" + ); + if control != "unknown_obligation" { + let bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + let result = authority::register_step_plan_commands(&c, &[command("O")]); + assert_eq!(result.is_err(), refused, "{control}: {result:?}"); + if matches!(control, "configured" | "unowned" | "already_registered") { + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(), bytes); + } + } + if control == "unknown_obligation" { + assert!( + admission::Admission::default() + .check(&c, None, &proposal_plan("O"), &mut proposal_plan("O"), 1) + .is_err() + ); + continue; + } + // The older, broader #479 formation rule is deliberately retained. + let original = proposal_plan("O"); + let decision = admission::Admission::default() + .check(&c, None, &original, &mut original.clone(), 1) + .unwrap(); + assert_eq!( + matches!(decision, admission::Decision::Retry(_)), + control != "configured", + "{control}" + ); + } +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_policy_normalization_generated_hooks_and_closed_contracts_stay_separate() { + let (_root, c, _guard, path) = setup(); + let before = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + for command in [ + format!("{} && {}", command("V2"), command("O")), + format!("{} || true", command("O")), + "cargo test --manifest-path ../Cargo.toml".into(), + ] { + assert!( + authority::register_step_plan_commands(&c, std::slice::from_ref(&command)).is_err(), + "{command}" + ); + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(), before); + } + // Baseline allows this command spelling at registration. The new rule + // requires literal argv and does not reinterpret shell expansion as proof. + let nonliteral = r#"node -e "$UNTRUSTED_SOURCE""#; + let contract = authority::load_for_handoff(&c).unwrap().unwrap(); + assert!(command_diagnosis::source_independent_inline_failure(&contract, nonliteral).is_none()); + assert_eq!( + crate::planner::verify::normalize_verify_command(nonliteral) + .unwrap() + .as_str(), + nonliteral + ); + let compound = "test -f README.md && npm run build".to_string(); + authority::register_step_plan_commands(&c, &[compound]).unwrap(); + let contract = authority::load_for_handoff(&c).unwrap().unwrap(); + assert_eq!(contract.verify_commands, ["npm run build"]); + let bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + let closed = authority::bind_for_recovery(&c, &[command("O")]).unwrap(); + authority::register_step_plan_commands(&closed, &[command("O")]).unwrap(); + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(), bytes); + for marker in [ + "data-anvil-action=\"primary\"", + "data-anvil-action=\"input\"", + "data-anvil-state", + ] { + let command = crate::planner::verify::normalize_verify_command(&format!( + "grep -q '{marker}' src/app/page.tsx" + )) + .unwrap(); + assert!( + command_diagnosis::source_independent_inline_failure(&contract, command.as_str()) + .is_none() + ); + } +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_contract_identity_is_checked_before_fixed_evidence_diagnosis() { + for name in ["O", "V2"] { + let (_root, mut c, _guard, path) = setup(); + // Attach a pre-existing frozen contract to exercise independent identity + // protection. The new preclosure guard must not reopen this contract. + let mut contract: CompletionContract = + serde_json::from_str(&fixture("contract.json")).unwrap(); + contract.verify_commands = vec![command(name)]; + std::fs::write(&path, serde_json::to_vec(&contract).unwrap()).unwrap(); + c.completion_contract_path = Some(path.clone()); + bind_context(&c); + assert!(crate::planner::recovery_inspection::has_origin(&c).unwrap()); + let mut bytes = std::fs::read(&path).unwrap(); + bytes.push(b' '); // Same semantics, changed frozen bytes. + std::fs::write(&path, &bytes).unwrap(); + let original = proposal_plan(name); + let error = admission::Admission::default() + .check( + &c, + Some("repair-markers"), + &original, + &mut original.clone(), + 1, + ) + .err() + .unwrap(); + assert!( + error.to_string().contains("contract changed"), + "{name}: {error:#}" + ); + assert!(!error.to_string().contains("weak inline")); + assert_eq!(std::fs::read(path).unwrap(), bytes); + } +} diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_runtime_tests.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_runtime_tests.rs new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ef78c4f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_runtime_tests.rs @@ -0,0 +1,92 @@ +use super::*; + +fn raw(root: &Path, command: &str) -> crate::bounded_process::BoundedProcessOutput { + crate::bounded_process::run_with_timeout( + std::process::Command::new("sh") + .args(["-c", command]) + .current_dir(root) + .stdout(std::process::Stdio::piped()) + .stderr(std::process::Stdio::piped()), + std::time::Duration::from_secs(5), + ) + .unwrap() +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_real_node_matrix_preserves_classification_and_failure_observations() { + let cases: Vec = serde_json::from_str(&fixture("matrix.json")).unwrap(); + assert_eq!(cases.len(), 24); + let mut observations = Vec::new(); + for case in cases { + let name = case["command"].as_str().unwrap(); + let variant = case["fixture"].as_str().unwrap(); + let (root, c, _guard, _) = setup(); + let page = root.path().join("src/app/page.tsx"); + if variant == "file_missing" { + std::fs::remove_file(page).unwrap(); + } else { + std::fs::write(page, fixture(&format!("fixtures/{variant}.txt"))).unwrap(); + } + let p = proposal_plan(name); + let command = &p.steps[0].verify[0]; + let output = raw(root.path(), command); + // Use the classifier's own literal parser, not shlex or a recorder's + // imitation. The exact argv below is also supplied to a real process. + let source = crate::minimal_loop::evidence::import_check::source(command).unwrap(); + let direct = crate::bounded_process::run_with_timeout( + std::process::Command::new("node") + .args(["-e", &source]) + .current_dir(root.path()) + .stdout(std::process::Stdio::piped()) + .stderr(std::process::Stdio::piped()), + std::time::Duration::from_secs(5), + ) + .unwrap(); + assert_eq!(direct.status, output.status); + assert_eq!(direct.stdout, output.stdout); + assert_eq!(direct.stderr, output.stderr); + let expected = case["execution_pass"].as_bool().unwrap(); + assert_eq!(output.success(), expected, "{name}/{variant}: {output:?}"); + if expected { + assert_eq!(output.stdout, b"ok\n"); + assert!(output.stderr.is_empty()); + } else { + assert!(output.stdout.is_empty()); + assert!(!output.stderr.is_empty()); + } + let report = crate::planner::verify::verify_step(root.path(), &p.steps[0]); + assert_eq!(report.is_pass(), expected, "{name}/{variant}: {report:?}"); + let diagnosis = command_diagnosis::collect(root.path(), std::slice::from_ref(command)); + assert_eq!(diagnosis[0].kind, case["kind"]); + let accepted = acceptance(&c, std::slice::from_ref(command)); + assert_eq!( + accepted + .weak_evidence + .iter() + .any(|w| w == "node_smoke_without_assertion"), + case["static_weak_evidence"].as_bool().unwrap() + ); + let decision = admission::Admission::default() + .check(&c, None, &p, &mut p.clone(), 1) + .unwrap(); + assert_eq!( + matches!(decision, admission::Decision::Retry(_)), + case["formation"] == "retry" + ); + assert_eq!( + scope::register(&c, &p).is_ok(), + case["registration"] == "accepted" + ); + observations.push(json!({"name":name,"fixture":variant,"command":command, + "classifier_parser_argv":["node", "-e", source], "shell_and_direct_outcomes_match":true, + "exit_code":output.status.and_then(|s|s.code()),"success":output.success(), + "stdout":String::from_utf8_lossy(&output.stdout), + "stderr_sha256":format!("{:x}",Sha256::digest(&output.stderr)), + "stderr_failure":String::from_utf8_lossy(&output.stderr).lines().find(|l| l.starts_with("Error:") || l.starts_with("AssertionError")), + "classification":diagnosis[0].kind, "execution_pass":report.is_pass(), + "static_acceptance":accepted.passed,"formation":case["formation"],"registration":case["registration"]})); + } + if let Ok(path) = std::env::var("ISSUE488_NODE_EVIDENCE") { + std::fs::write(path, serde_json::to_vec_pretty(&observations).unwrap()).unwrap(); + } +} diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_tests.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_tests.rs new file mode 100644 index 00000000..702a9dd5 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/issue488_tests.rs @@ -0,0 +1,119 @@ +use super::*; +use crate::minimal_loop::evidence::{command_diagnosis, verify_runtime_acceptance_with_hints}; +use sha2::{Digest, Sha256}; + +fn fixture(name: &str) -> String { + std::fs::read_to_string( + Path::new(env!("CARGO_MANIFEST_DIR")) + .join("tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline") + .join(name), + ) + .unwrap() +} + +fn command(name: &str) -> String { + let data: serde_json::Value = serde_json::from_str(&fixture("commands.json")).unwrap(); + let command = data[name]["command"].as_str().unwrap(); + assert_eq!( + format!("{:x}", Sha256::digest(command.as_bytes())), + data[name]["sha256"] + ); + command.into() +} + +fn setup() -> ( + tempfile::TempDir, + Config, + authority::RunAuthorityGuard, + std::path::PathBuf, +) { + let root = tempfile::tempdir().unwrap(); + let c = super::issue478::nextjs_config(root.path()); + std::fs::write( + root.path().join("src/app/page.tsx"), + fixture("fixtures/normal.txt"), + ) + .unwrap(); + std::fs::write(root.path().join("README.md"), "D4 marker fixture").unwrap(); + let guard = authority::begin_run(&c); + let path = generated_contract(&c); + std::fs::write(&path, fixture("contract.json")).unwrap(); + (root, c, guard, path) +} + +fn proposal_plan(name: &str) -> StepPlan { + let mut check = step("check-markers", "verify", &[]); + check.instruction = "Check the saved source markers.".into(); + check.verify = vec![command(name)]; + StepPlan { + goal: "Verify saved source markers".into(), + steps: vec![check], + } +} + +fn acceptance( + c: &Config, + commands: &[String], +) -> crate::minimal_loop::evidence::RuntimeAcceptanceReport { + let contract: CompletionContract = serde_json::from_str(&fixture("contract.json")).unwrap(); + verify_runtime_acceptance_with_hints( + &c.workspace_root, + &contract.required_paths, + commands, + &contract.required_capabilities, + &contract.required_evidence, + &contract.required_obligations, + &[], + &contract.evidence_hint_tokens, + ) +} + +#[test] +fn issue488_real_formation_registration_and_final_boundary() { + for name in ["O", "V1", "V2", "SWALLOW"] { + let (_root, c, _guard, path) = setup(); + let original = proposal_plan(name); + let mut admission = admission::Admission::default(); + let decision = admission + .check(&c, None, &original, &mut original.clone(), 1) + .unwrap(); + assert_eq!( + matches!(decision, admission::Decision::Retry(_)), + name != "V2" + ); + if name != "V2" { + let fixed = proposal_plan("V2"); + assert!(matches!( + admission + .check(&c, None, &fixed, &mut fixed.clone(), 2) + .unwrap(), + admission::Decision::Ready(false) + )); + } + let registration = scope::register(&c, &original); + assert_eq!(registration.is_ok(), name == "V2"); + let contract: CompletionContract = + serde_json::from_slice(&std::fs::read(path).unwrap()).unwrap(); + assert_eq!( + contract.verify_commands.contains(&command(name)), + name == "V2" + ); + let report = acceptance(&c, &[command(name)]); + assert_eq!(report.passed, name == "V2", "{name}: {report:?}"); + let diagnosis = command_diagnosis::collect(&c.workspace_root, &[command(name)]); + eprintln!( + "current {name}: formation_retry={} registration_ok={registration:?} final_pass={} kind={}", + name != "V2", + report.passed, + diagnosis[0].kind + ); + } +} + +#[path = "issue488_runtime_tests.rs"] +mod runtime; + +#[path = "issue488_planner_tests.rs"] +mod planner; +#[path = "issue488_registration_tests.rs"] +mod registration; diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/literal_marker_formation.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/literal_marker_formation.rs new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5e99a3d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/literal_marker_formation.rs @@ -0,0 +1,220 @@ +//! Closed file-marker strengthening grammar, not a JavaScript equivalence engine. +//! Regexes qualify only when their entire pattern denotes one literal substring. +use super::*; +use crate::minimal_loop::evidence::import_check; +use crate::planner::recovery_contract_authority::{inline_admission, verifier_obligations}; + +#[derive(Clone, PartialEq, Eq, serde::Serialize)] +pub(super) struct Obligation { + pub original_command: String, + pub normalized_command: String, + pub original_step: String, + pub original_step_index: usize, + pub expected_result: String, + pub predicates: Predicates, +} + +#[derive(Clone, PartialEq, Eq, serde::Serialize)] +pub(super) struct Predicates { + target: String, + // Order and diagnostic messages are part of the retained contract. + checks: Vec<(String, String)>, + stdout: String, +} + +pub(super) fn capture( + config: &Config, + contract: &CompletionContract, + plan: &StepPlan, +) -> Vec { + let Ok(admitted) = verifier_obligations::admitted_commands(config, contract, plan) else { + return Vec::new(); + }; + let mut obligations = Vec::new(); + for (index, step) in plan.steps.iter().enumerate() { + if step.expected_result != "pass" { + continue; + } + for command in &step.verify { + let Ok(normalized) = crate::planner::verify::normalize_planner_verify_command(command) + else { + continue; + }; + // Existing normalization can split compounds. Projection does not + // prove compound equivalence; retain those via existing scope rules. + let [normalized] = normalized.as_slice() else { + continue; + }; + if !admitted.contains(normalized) + || !inline_admission::refusal(config, contract, normalized) + .is_ok_and(|r| r.is_some()) + { + continue; + } + if let Some((predicates, _)) = parse(normalized) { + obligations.push(Obligation { + original_command: command.clone(), + normalized_command: normalized.clone(), + original_step: step.id.clone(), + original_step_index: index, + expected_result: step.expected_result.clone(), + predicates, + }); + } + } + } + obligations +} + +pub(super) fn matches(obligation: &Obligation, candidate: &str) -> bool { + parse(candidate) + .is_some_and(|(predicates, direct)| direct && predicates == obligation.predicates) +} + +pub(super) fn preserve_raw_commands( + obligations: &[Obligation], + model: &StepPlan, +) -> anyhow::Result<()> { + for command in model.steps.iter().flat_map(|s| &s.verify) { + let normalized = + crate::planner::verify::normalize_planner_verify_command(command).unwrap_or_default(); + if obligations + .iter() + .any(|o| !matches(o, command) && normalized.iter().any(|c| matches(o, c))) + { + return Err(crate::planner::recovery_inspection::verifier_obligations::failure( + crate::planner::recovery_inspection::verifier_obligations::FailureClass::ProposalRepairable, + "literal-marker replacement must explicitly preserve the predicates, stdout and failure propagation without shell wrappers", + )); + } + } + Ok(()) +} + +pub(super) fn guidance(obligations: &[Obligation]) -> String { + if obligations.is_empty() { + return String::new(); + } + format!( + "\nThe current classifier cannot recognize the original failure path (an assert may already be present). For the captured literal file-marker checks only, explicitly propose direct assert(s.includes(literal),message) checks with identical file, ordered conditions, messages and console.log output; remove swallowing catches. This is a text check, not proof of application behavior. Preserve all owner/output duties and other gates. Saved draft obligations:\n{}", + serde_json::to_string(obligations).expect("serializable marker obligations") + ) +} + +fn parse(command: &str) -> Option<(Predicates, bool)> { + let source = import_check::source(command)?; + let (assert_bound, rest) = + match source.strip_prefix("const assert=require('node:assert/strict');") { + Some(rest) => (true, rest), + None => (false, source.as_str()), + }; + let rest = rest.strip_prefix("const s=require('fs').readFileSync('")?; + let (target, mut rest) = rest.split_once("','utf8');")?; + // No escape or computed path; path spelling is retained exactly. + if target.is_empty() + || !target + .bytes() + .all(|b| b.is_ascii_alphanumeric() || b"_./-[]".contains(&b)) + { + return None; + } + verifier_obligations::normalized(target).ok()?; + let mut checks = Vec::new(); + let mut direct = true; + let stdout; + loop { + rest = rest.trim_start(); + if let Some(tail) = rest.strip_prefix("console.log(") { + let (value, tail) = quoted(tail)?; + if !matches!(tail, ")" | ");") || checks.is_empty() { + return None; + } + stdout = value; + break; + } + let (literal, message, tail, is_direct) = if let Some(tail) = rest.strip_prefix("if(!/") { + let (pattern, tail) = tail.split_once("/.test(s))throw new Error(")?; + let (message, tail) = quoted(tail)?; + ( + regex_literal(pattern)?, + message, + tail.strip_prefix(");")?, + false, + ) + } else { + if !assert_bound { + return None; + } + let (swallowed, tail) = rest + .strip_prefix("try{") + .map_or((false, rest), |r| (true, r)); + let (literal, tail, includes) = if let Some(tail) = + tail.strip_prefix("assert(s.includes(") + { + let (literal, tail) = quoted(tail)?; + (literal, tail.strip_prefix("),")?, true) + } else { + let (pattern, tail) = tail.strip_prefix("assert(/")?.split_once("/.test(s),")?; + (regex_literal(pattern)?, tail, false) + }; + let (message, tail) = quoted(tail)?; + let tail = tail.strip_prefix(");")?; + let tail = if swallowed { + tail.strip_prefix("}catch(error){};")? + } else { + tail + }; + (literal, message, tail, includes && !swallowed) + }; + if literal.is_empty() { + return None; + } + checks.push((literal, message)); + direct &= is_direct; + rest = tail; + } + Some(( + Predicates { + target: target.into(), + checks, + stdout, + }, + direct, + )) +} + +/// Intentionally closed ASCII JS string grammar; no escapes/interpolation or +/// embedded executable fragments. Shell quoting is decoded by the final parser. +fn quoted(source: &str) -> Option<(String, &str)> { + let quote = source.chars().next()?; + if !matches!(quote, '\'' | '"') { + return None; + } + let (value, tail) = source[1..].split_once(quote)?; + if !value + .bytes() + .all(|b| b.is_ascii_alphanumeric() || b" _-=:./\"[]".contains(&b)) + { + return None; + } + Some((value.into(), tail)) +} + +fn regex_literal(pattern: &str) -> Option { + let mut literal = String::new(); + let mut chars = pattern.chars(); + while let Some(ch) = chars.next() { + if ch == '\\' { + let escaped = chars.next()?; + if !".[](){}*+?^$|/\\\"".contains(escaped) { + return None; + } + literal.push(escaped); + } else if ch.is_ascii_alphanumeric() || " _-=: \"".contains(ch) { + literal.push(ch); + } else { + return None; + } + } + Some(literal) +} diff --git a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/verifier_formation.rs b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/verifier_formation.rs index 9e3ca9dd..9f9f2f63 100644 --- a/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/verifier_formation.rs +++ b/src/planner/recovery_step_plan_binding/verifier_formation.rs @@ -14,12 +14,15 @@ pub(super) struct Replacement { reason: &'static str, #[serde(skip_serializing_if = "Option::is_none")] package_script: Option, + #[serde(skip_serializing_if = "Option::is_none")] + literal_markers: Option, } pub(super) fn project( original: &StepPlan, proposed: &StepPlan, package_scripts: Option<&super::package_script_formation::PackageScripts>, + marker_checks: &[super::literal_marker_formation::Obligation], ) -> (StepPlan, Vec) { let mut projected = proposed.clone(); let mut records = Vec::new(); @@ -54,6 +57,7 @@ pub(super) fn project( "identical_import_then_direct_target_assertion_without_catch" }, package_script: None, + literal_markers: None, }); *replacement = command.clone(); } @@ -77,6 +81,28 @@ pub(super) fn project( expected_result: obligation.expected_result.clone(), replacement_command: replacement.clone(), reason: "saved_package_script_literal_strict_comparison_then_original_output", package_script: Some(obligation.clone()), + literal_markers: None, + }); + *replacement = obligation.original_command.clone(); + } + } + } + } + for obligation in marker_checks { + for candidate in &mut projected.steps { + if candidate.expected_result != obligation.expected_result { + continue; + } + for replacement in &mut candidate.verify { + if super::literal_marker_formation::matches(obligation, replacement) { + records.push(Replacement { + original_command: obligation.original_command.clone(), + import_target: None, + expected_result: obligation.expected_result.clone(), + replacement_command: replacement.clone(), + reason: "identical_file_ordered_literal_predicates_and_output_without_catch", + package_script: None, + literal_markers: Some(obligation.clone()), }); *replacement = obligation.original_command.clone(); } diff --git a/src/planner/runner/phase/recovery_authority.rs b/src/planner/runner/phase/recovery_authority.rs index f53452d4..55b67eb8 100644 --- a/src/planner/runner/phase/recovery_authority.rs +++ b/src/planner/runner/phase/recovery_authority.rs @@ -70,3 +70,7 @@ mod issue479_acceptance_tests; #[cfg(test)] #[path = "../../final_acceptance/issue480_tests.rs"] mod issue480_acceptance_tests; + +#[cfg(test)] +#[path = "../../final_acceptance/issue488_tests.rs"] +mod issue488_acceptance_tests; diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/README.md b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/README.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..86672245 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,84 @@ +# Issue #488 D4 inline checks + +Baseline: `85dd5fdd12b831deb49e7b3fe9e996c01f1fab67`. Exact command strings and +SHA256 in `commands.json` were extracted from the complete Issue #488 body and +checked against the immutable C5 `inputs/commands.json` below: + +`workspace/tmp/0915/recovery-improvement-execution-01/c5-d4-linked-controls-20260916-01/` + +C5 commit `f0aceed8c44748855a543ae7a122e3ffefb43cbc` and parent develop +`e99f1ebe` plus WIP are separate contexts, not code transplanted into this change. +No historical evidence, old instrument, parent WIP, credentials or live state is +included. `contract.json` is the Issue's minimal initial generated contract. +The test establishes ownership with `begin_run`/`record_generated_contract`. + +## Fixtures and expected stages + +`src/app/page.tsx` and `fixtures/normal.txt` have the four requested marker lines. +`primary.txt`, `input.txt`, `state.txt` and `snapshot.txt` each omit just the named +condition. The sixth fixture is created by removing the file in a temporary test +workspace. These are new reduced text fixtures, not a buildable Next.js app and +not a rerun of the historical C-2 app or all 24 C5 cases. + +`matrix.json` specifies 4 commands × 6 fixtures. The focused test consumes its +execution/classification/formation/registration expectations. Final isolated +acceptance additionally requires command success and required paths/evidence. +The generic corpus test exercises O's real static weak-evidence refusal. + +| command | real Node normal / missing marker / missing file | final classification | formation / new registration | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| O | 0 / nonzero / nonzero | weak | retry / reject | +| V1 | 0 / nonzero / nonzero | weak | retry / reject | +| V2 | 0 / nonzero / nonzero | Test | ready / accept | +| SWALLOW | 0 / 0 / nonzero | weak | retry / reject | + +V1 already has assertions. O and V1 detect omissions at runtime, but the current +conservative classifier does not recognize their regex failure path. The reason +`node_smoke_without_assertion` is preserved for compatibility, not interpreted as +proof of absent assertions. Classification is independent of fixture contents. +The real process test compares shell execution with **the classifier's parser** +and a second Node process using that exact parsed argv, checking stdout/stderr +and exit status for every case. Shell-process argv is not observed; the saved +`classifier_parser_argv` is supplied to the direct process only. The old +disqualified argv recorder is not reused. + +## Scope and controls + +A literal-marker rewrite preserves the exact file path, four ordered conditions, +diagnostic messages, stdout, pass result and model/host owner/output boundaries. +The supported whole-program grammar excludes arbitrary JS, nonliteral regexes, +extra statements and shell wrappers. `refusals.json` is consumed by mock-provider +regressions for condition/target/output/owner/result/order loss and masking. + +The four mock series cover accepted repair, three weak replies, weakened repair, +and fallback. The last-valid positive case actually reaches the driver's +quality → lint/schema degradation → saved-plan return; a separate case observes +formation Retry clearing that saved plan. Direct finish checks are additional +controls, not evidence that a driver branch ran. All provider replies are local +successful mocks; provider transport retries and Recovery budgets are unchanged. + +All three registration entries test both mixed-candidate orders and all-good +batches, including verifier creation obligations. Configured/unowned/registered +contracts and Config profile/intent/requirement controls distinguish no new rule +from the older broad #479 rejection. Existing normalization rejects unsplittable +inline compounds; simple `test -f ... && npm run build` still splits. Baseline +command policy accepts a nonliteral Node spelling; the new literal-only rule does +not change that policy or grant it evidence. No nonliteral command is executed. + +`business-controls.json` is synthetic data tested by an independent real Node +oracle and handed to the existing behavior gate. It is not an observation of an +app saving or reloading. Compiler failure is likewise a synthetic observation +at the existing report boundary. The final executor tests use a generic profile +to isolate command/evidence behavior and separately assert the Next.js profile +still rejects this reduced non-app fixture. This baseline has no separate +`source_verifier_admission` or C5 fixed-verifier routing module; those parent WIP +modules are not imported. Existing Next.js profile, compile, behavior and frozen +contract-byte identity gates remain in force. + +## Difference from existing corpora + +#479 covers pure imports, export-set refinements and generated structural checks; +#484 covers saved package-script literals and their model/host owners. This corpus +adds exact D4 regex/assert/swallowed marker checks, finite literal-file rewrites, +registration atomicity at every entry and the real driver return controls. +Run `cargo test issue488 --lib` and `cargo test --test corpus_regression`. diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/business-controls.json b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/business-controls.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1dc996ab --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/business-controls.json @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +{ + "positive": {"saved": true, "reloaded": true}, + "negative": {"saved": true, "reloaded": false}, + "scope": "Synthetic observation -> independent Node oracle -> existing behavior gate; not a live app observation" +} diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/commands.json b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/commands.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e2bca504 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/commands.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "O": { + "command": "node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\"", + "sha256": "e5c561799e5d8da640ae8d6b8420f7d8417db8d80ed72105373a6214d8eb4283" + }, + "V1": { + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(/data-anvil-state/.test(s),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(/JSON\\\\.stringify/.test(s),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "sha256": "21cbfbd24dd78a0050556defd4b4240c54d182fd740124acd8dd49122bb2b1db" + }, + "V2": { + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\"); assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\"); assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\"); console.log('ok')\"", + "sha256": "396e99a87c78d3b8a4e683dc0586cdb792aa71ca1c310798c05b7486e65596ab" + }, + "SWALLOW": { + "command": "node -e \"const assert=require('node:assert/strict');const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"'),\\\"missing primary\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"'),\\\"missing input\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('data-anvil-state'),\\\"missing state\\\");}catch(error){}; try{assert(s.includes('JSON.stringify'),\\\"missing JSON snapshot\\\");}catch(error){}; console.log('ok')\"", + "sha256": "d1e4ef5a2270edddb5b0ec3f0a68147b38c0d1499ff7d29389eab5e256c405e8" + } +} diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/contract.json b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/contract.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4bb3d38d --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/contract.json @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +{ + "required_paths": [ + "README.md", + "src/app/page.tsx" + ], + "protected_paths": [], + "verify_commands": [], + "profile": "nextjs", + "goal": "Verify saved source markers", + "required_capabilities": [], + "deterministic_oracles": [], + "required_evidence": [ + "requested_content_evidence" + ], + "evidence_hint_tokens": [], + "required_obligations": [], + "deferred_verify_requirements": [], + "verify_repair_cap": 2 +} diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/expectations.toml b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/expectations.toml new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0f110f75 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/expectations.toml @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +case_id = "issue488-d4-inline" +source = "Exact D4 commands; reduced text fixtures; real Node and mock-provider Rust tests" +required_paths = ["README.md", "src/app/page.tsx"] +verify_commands = ["node -e \"const s=require('fs').readFileSync('src/app/page.tsx','utf8'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"primary\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing primary'); if(!/data-anvil-action=\\\"input\\\"/.test(s))throw new Error('missing input'); if(!/data-anvil-state/.test(s))throw new Error('missing state'); if(!/JSON\\.stringify/.test(s))throw new Error('missing JSON snapshot'); console.log('ok')\""] +required_capabilities = [] +required_evidence = ["requested_content_evidence"] +required_obligations = [] +acceptance_passed = false +primary_reason = "weak_verification_evidence:node_smoke_without_assertion" + +[weak_evidence] +contains = ["node_smoke_without_assertion"] + +[compile] +expect = "not_checked" + +[fixture_contains] +commands.json = ["e5c561799e5d8da640ae8d6b8420f7d8417db8d80ed72105373a6214d8eb4283", "SWALLOW"] diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/input.txt b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/input.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..821c06a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/input.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +data-anvil-action="primary" +data-anvil-state +JSON.stringify diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/normal.txt b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/normal.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5337afdd --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/normal.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +data-anvil-action="primary" +data-anvil-action="input" +data-anvil-state +JSON.stringify diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/primary.txt b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/primary.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c2cc2cf8 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/primary.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +data-anvil-action="input" +data-anvil-state +JSON.stringify diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/snapshot.txt b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/snapshot.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..94ae7be7 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/snapshot.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +data-anvil-action="primary" +data-anvil-action="input" +data-anvil-state diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/state.txt b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/state.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..2a7e4c2b --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/fixtures/state.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +data-anvil-action="primary" +data-anvil-action="input" +JSON.stringify diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/matrix.json b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/matrix.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c32ed501 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/matrix.json @@ -0,0 +1,242 @@ +[ + { + "command": "O", + "fixture": "normal", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "O", + "fixture": "primary", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "O", + "fixture": "input", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "O", + "fixture": "state", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "O", + "fixture": "snapshot", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "O", + "fixture": "file_missing", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "V1", + "fixture": "normal", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "V1", + "fixture": "primary", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "V1", + "fixture": "input", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "V1", + "fixture": "state", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "V1", + "fixture": "snapshot", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "V1", + "fixture": "file_missing", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "V2", + "fixture": "normal", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "test", + "formation": "ready", + "registration": "accepted", + "final_isolated_pass": true, + "static_weak_evidence": false + }, + { + "command": "V2", + "fixture": "primary", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "test", + "formation": "ready", + "registration": "accepted", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": false + }, + { + "command": "V2", + "fixture": "input", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "test", + "formation": "ready", + "registration": "accepted", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": false + }, + { + "command": "V2", + "fixture": "state", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "test", + "formation": "ready", + "registration": "accepted", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": false + }, + { + "command": "V2", + "fixture": "snapshot", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "test", + "formation": "ready", + "registration": "accepted", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": false + }, + { + "command": "V2", + "fixture": "file_missing", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "test", + "formation": "ready", + "registration": "accepted", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": false + }, + { + "command": "SWALLOW", + "fixture": "normal", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "SWALLOW", + "fixture": "primary", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "SWALLOW", + "fixture": "input", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "SWALLOW", + "fixture": "state", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "SWALLOW", + "fixture": "snapshot", + "execution_pass": true, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + }, + { + "command": "SWALLOW", + "fixture": "file_missing", + "execution_pass": false, + "kind": "weak", + "formation": "retry", + "registration": "rejected", + "final_isolated_pass": false, + "static_weak_evidence": true + } +] diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/refusals.json b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/refusals.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..bab58065 --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/refusals.json @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +[ + "three_weak", + "condition", + "target", + "stdout", + "message", + "output", + "model_owner", + "host_owner", + "expected_result", + "owner_order", + "condition_order", + "other_check", + "success_override", + "unknown_regex", + "shell_override" +] diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/source-manifest.json b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/source-manifest.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..aebbeeae --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/source-manifest.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "baseline": "85dd5fdd12b831deb49e7b3fe9e996c01f1fab67", + "historical_C5": "f0aceed8c44748855a543ae7a122e3ffefb43cbc", + "historical_commands_sha256": "80197a586620817913c26df2734f3f37dcc657b7178e6228a118a1a142a5051a", + "scope": "Exact saved commands; new reduced fixtures; no parent WIP or old recorder reused", + "fixture_sha256": { + "README.md": "25ebc6ed816c321de51ed724cd1468f27c0e4e6439c9b99efef05aeff223b3b5", + "business-controls.json": "8840bc6912d58529cd3a12bfd9e14b17d4a129dc1edf9533deec3f9e949f4211", + "commands.json": "2c01b21a975644a43c18c7bd62d7192ba93129018b9acc6e94606ac27f921df2", + "contract.json": "ebb697c35564072213040a6e2c3ada6bab7fcc123e545fc13fd38ae1db046668", + "expectations.toml": "75c327b98f556a69626fb25c198429e163c5bfc7a2c8baa4bf967a681301470c", + "fixtures/input.txt": "128701f00239df5e4689fdbc0b34775e7cb11659812792db3cba379acc079629", + "fixtures/normal.txt": "b4a1e73e67c78876def8e8bb79730292791e80408e4ac2d6bd9c1a666e36579c", + "fixtures/primary.txt": "e3036b9bf7f1360f29ca791419238ea3ea9ee6e3e2a6f0095d0c2cdece11b753", + "fixtures/snapshot.txt": "b1a26dce6be7db96b5bea2e99ac1f9d198bec554e149ad96d400f93f1871e180", + "fixtures/state.txt": "83a1932662e98232e2861134c044604d8b2cbabfc18a8155427f279bdca5481a", + "matrix.json": "94ff26c76bca36fb75a9acc0bc127beadfd3f328f6009dc32c2bcf431d04acbb", + "refusals.json": "a27c5f26db924f2b5ead0ad859de4950410eabe7ace85d4e72c90607dcee67ed", + "src/app/page.tsx": "b4a1e73e67c78876def8e8bb79730292791e80408e4ac2d6bd9c1a666e36579c" + } +} diff --git a/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/src/app/page.tsx b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/src/app/page.tsx new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5337afdd --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/corpus/apps/issue488-d4-inline/src/app/page.tsx @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +data-anvil-action="primary" +data-anvil-action="input" +data-anvil-state +JSON.stringify